About

Posts by :

Video: Our Photographer on Capturing the Bullet Streaking Past Trump

Video: Our Photographer on Capturing the Bullet Streaking Past Trump

new video loaded: Our Photographer on Capturing the Bullet Streaking Past Trump

By Doug Mills, Nikolay Nikolov, Rebecca Suner and Alexandra OstasiewiczJuly 14, 2024

Doug Mills, a veteran photographer for The New York Times, was only a few feet away from former President Donald J. Trump at the rally in Butler, Pa., when the shooting started. Mr. Mills kept his finger on the shutter button, photographing as the scene unfolded. It was only afterward, while reviewing his photos, that he realized he had captured the apparent path of a bullet used in the assassination attempt against the former president. He explains what he saw.

Recent episodes in Behind the Reporting

Local world-class photographer exhibit opens

Local world-class photographer exhibit opens
image

MAYVILLE, N.Y. — Renowned photographer Dr. John Gerber is set to unveil his latest photography exhibit, showcasing the awe-inspiring journey of the wildebeest during the Great Migration.

The exhibit documents the wildebeest’s remarkable 1,100-mile seasonal trek across the Mara River, from Kenya to their calving grounds in Tanzania.

Gerber, Mayville resident and world-class international photographer, has traveled extensively, capturing breathtaking moments in Africa, India, Brazil, Patagonia and beyond.

Reflecting on his work, Gerber said, “By photographing our planet’s last great migration, I hope to show that beauty can be found even in the harshest of circumstances and environments.”

Accompanying the exhibit is Gerber’s latest book, “Songs of the Serengeti, Meditations on Wildebeest,” a photo essay chronicling the struggles and triumphs of Serengeti. The book intertwines imagery with Gerber’s reflections, offering a blend of visual and literary artistry.

“The Great Migration” photography exhibit will be on display at The Sheep Barn Gallery, 5155 Morris Road in Mayville, from Aug. 10 to Sept. 8, with open gallery hours from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. Fridays and Saturdays and 1 to 4 p.m. Sundays.

The exhibit is free and open to the public. For additional information and event updates, visit johngerberphotography.com or email hello@johngerberphotography.com.

‘I have to do my job.’ Photojournalists capture images of Trump shooting

‘I have to do my job.’ Photojournalists capture images of Trump shooting

For many Americans, the horror and gravity of Saturday night’s shooting at a rally for Donald Trump in Pennsylvania was quickly brought home by an image: the former president, blood streaking down his face, raising his fist in defiance.

One of the most widely shared photos was captured by Associated Press chief photographer Evan Vucci. It was one of several taken in the aftermath of the shooting that are sure to go down in the pantheon of American photography.

“The pinnacle of photojournalism. A perfectly framed and composed image of historic breaking news,” New York Times journalist Matina Stevis-Gridneff wrote on X of Vucci’s photo.

As Trump began to speak on Saturday, four newsroom photographers had been arranged around the stage in an area known as the buffer, which was only five or 10 feet from the president. When the shooting began, the photographers scrambled to get to a better position to capture the chaos, potentially putting themselves in the line of fire in the process.

According to the photographers, the Trump team normally gives the pool of photographers about five minutes at the start of every campaign speech to take photos; in this case, because the shooting happened near the beginning of the event, the photographers were able to capture it from up close.

Vucci was on the left side of the stage and ran to where he thought Trump would exit after the shooting began, along with other photographers.

“The only thing I kept telling myself was: ‘Slow down. Slow down. Compose. Slow down.’” he said. “I knew I had to get this. This was such an important moment in American history. It needed to be documented. If you’re not keeping a level head, you can’t do the job.”

Vucci, a 20-year veteran of the wire service, said he wasn’t scared — even as some campaign staffers worried about a possible second shooter. “I never thought about it for a second,” he said. “I have to be there. I can’t hide. I can’t duck behind the stage. I have to do my job.”

Jabin Botsford, a photographer for The Washington Post, was moving from the back of the stage to the front when the shooting began.

“I heard the first pop, and I was like: ‘Oh, weird. Fireworks,’” he said. “It was super scary. Nobody knew what was going on. The president fell to the ground, and I was going to make a picture of it even though the staff was like, ‘You guys need to get down.’”

Botsford was also able to take a video of the aftermath because he was wearing Ray-Ban Meta smart glasses that can take 30-second videos, which he “somehow” remembered to turn on.

Washington Post photographer Jabin Botsford covered the Trump rally shooting on July 13 in Butler, Pa. Here’s what he saw. (Video: Jabin Botsford/The Washington Post)

Times photographer Doug Mills was able to capture what appears to be the stream of the bullet in the air, as it whizzed by Trump’s head. Former Associated Press photographer Haraz N. Ghanbari called it “a remarkable photo.”

Mills, in an interview with the Times, said the pool photographers “were all jostling around in there trying to get our normal pictures,” until he heard what he thought was a popping noise made by a car. Trump “went down behind the lectern, and I thought, ‘Oh my God, something’s happened.’”

While he scrambled to get a better shot, Mills said he feared for his life. “At first I thought right away, ‘Could I be shot?’ It was scary. I’ve never been in a more horrific scene.”

Getty staff photographer Anna Moneymaker was able to capture Trump on the stage, seemingly taken between the legs of an officer.

The photographers received widespread praise for their work, particularly amid a violent and chaotic situation. “Their iconic photographs were immediately seen around the world and will be added to the indelible visual record of history,” said Jessica Koscielniak, president of the White House News Photographers Association. “Yesterday’s event only reinforces the critical importance and need for visual journalists to be present and in close proximity to candidates and elected officials.”

After the shooting, the photographers went to a holding tent for about 30 minutes, Mills said. They emerged to take pictures of the emptied field and the items that remained, including cellphones and a motorized wheelchair.

“We just walked into total emptiness,” Botsford said.

Vucci was among the photographers at the Associated Press who won a Pulitzer Prize in 2021 for coverage of the protests that followed the police killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis. He has also photographed combat in Iraq and Afghanistan, an experience he said helped him remain calm and composed.

“My job as a photographer is to just show the viewer, though my eyes, the world in front of me,” he said. “I felt like all of us did that.”

Botsford, like Vucci, got little time to rest or reflect on what happened Saturday.

“I’m still trying to process it all,” he said from his hotel in Milwaukee on Sunday. “There’s a lot going on in my head. It’s still, like, disbelief.”

A Legendary American Photograph

A Legendary American Photograph

Donald Trump raises a fist. Blood streaks his face. The sky is high, blue, and empty except for an American flag caught in a hard wind. A Secret Service agent has her arms around his waist. The former president’s mouth is open, in the middle of a snarled shout. We know from video footage that he is yelling “Fight!,” that the crowd is chanting “USA!”

The photograph, by the Associated Press’s Evan Vucci, became immediately legendary. However you feel about the man at its center, it is undeniably one of the great compositions in U.S. photographic history. Although I am deeply relieved that Trump survived this assassination attempt, I am no fan of his. But the first time I saw the photo, I felt an emotion that I later recognized, with considerable discomfort, as a fluttering of unbidden nationalist zeal. What encapsulates our American ideal more than bloody defiance and stubborn pride that teeters just on the edge of foolishness? No hunkering and no hiding—standing undaunted and undeterred, fist-pumping your way through an attempted murder. It was a moment when Trump supporters’ idea of him—strong, resilient, proud—collided with reality.

I can’t help but be moved by this remarkable image, taken by a Pulitzer Prize winner who ran toward the danger, camera in hand, rather than away from it. There is a perverse and paradoxical disjunction between Trump the man, who many argue is a threat to American democracy, and this image of Trump, which seems to capture that same democracy in all its pathology, mythos, and, yes, glory. The Compact editor Sohrab Ahmari tweeted that Trump’s instinct—to reflexively gesture in rebellion after being shot at—is “evidence of a truly extraordinary man.” He is more than a little right. Extraordinary, after all, is not so much a moral descriptor as an aesthetic one.

The image of Trump, bloody with a raised fist, is destined to adorn T-shirts, magazine covers, full-page spreads in history books, campaign ads. I do not think it is an exaggeration to say that the photo is nearly perfect, one captured under extreme duress and that distills the essence of a man in all his contradictions.

Many commentators have already surmised that this image alone will cost our current president his reelection bid. Some rushed to juxtapose pictures of Joe Biden, staring awkwardly and looking frail, with an angry, almost-assassinated Trump. One writer took to X to place the Vucci photo side by side with a still from the film Oppenheimer, implying that the photographer, like the inventor of the atomic bomb, may one day come to feel that his greatest achievement slipped out of his control and ushered in a darker world. The left-wing political commentator Cenk Uygur, summarized things more simply still: “Trump sticking the hand up and saying, ‘Fight, fight, fight!’ while the crowd chanted ‘USA, USA, USA!’ was bad ass.”

All of these reactions, whether fear or resentment or grudging admiration, are understandable. But I wonder whether they miss the point. The real subject of this photograph is not Donald Trump but his supporters. Many of us have mocked Trump stans—their ridiculous fan art that reimagines him with bulging muscles or fighting in the Revolutionary War; their unshakable and cultish belief in his vigor; their desperate desire to see him as he wants to be seen rather than as he is. Yesterday, for a few moments at least, the Trump of MAGA’s imagination and reality became indistinguishable. Not even the most slavish devotee of the former president could have dreamed up a more iconic portrait.

Today, Americans are not unified. We are not “All MAGA,” as a viral headline this morning suggests. We are angry, bitter, and divided; paranoid and afraid; governed by two parties that seem constitutionally incapable of putting America above their own interests. What happened yesterday does nothing to change that. Nor do a few seconds of real bravery absolve Trump of his sins, or make his political platform more palatable. But I would suggest that Democrats and anti-Trumpers take a break from contextualizing and problematizing and hypothesizing and worrying, and instead spend some time contemplating, if only for a minute or two, this photograph. The man, the flag, the blood, the fist.

It is often difficult for Trump critics to inhabit the mind of one of his supporters, to understand Trump’s appeal without immediately defaulting to simplifications like racism and misogyny, explanations that have become less of a skeleton key and more of a shibboleth, particularly as the former president continues to see his support among minorities swell. Vucci has provided us not with an alternative theory of the case but with a badly needed window into the MAGA mindset, allowing all of America, and indeed the world, to see Trump through the eyes of his devotees, people we share this country with.

If Democrats hope to beat Trump and Trumpism, they need to understand the appeal. Which means they need to be able to look at this image and see a promise—one I do not believe Trump can deliver, but a promise nonetheless—of toughness, vitality, and unbowing resolve at a moment when we are wavering, weak, and irresolute before a graying future. The photograph is not a portrait of a man but a through-the-looking-glass vision of America as she would have herself and as many in this country would have her. Our oldest myths briefly became real one bright evening in Butler, Pennsylvania.

Tyler Austin Harper is an assistant professor of environmental studies at Bates College and a contributing writer at The Atlantic.

Businesses Able to Sponsor Rescue Dog Photoshoots by West Hartford Photographer – We-Ha

Businesses Able to Sponsor Rescue Dog Photoshoots by West Hartford Photographer – We-Ha

A West Hartford pet photographer who was moved to launch her career to help shelter animals find homes, is offering a sponsorship program.

By Grayson Rivers

“Capturing” and “shooting” – words no one wants to hear in a rescue dog story. But for West Hartford pet photographer Sara Huber, capturing and shooting portraits is her way of bringing rescue dogs to their forever homes. 

Owner of the photography business Paw Print Studio, Huber has been offering her expertise to various Connecticut rescues since 2016, free of charge. Now, local businesses have the opportunity to join her new “Rescue Photoshoot Sponsor” program, covering a day-long photoshoot for a minimum of 10 dogs while at the same time boosting their exposure. 

This program comes at a great time, too. With the adoption-frenzy of the COVID-19 pandemic slowing to a halt, animal rescue organizations are finding it increasingly difficult to secure new pet parents, an important task that allows dogs from out-of-state to escape packed kill-shelters. 

That’s where Huber comes in, providing the nonprofits with professional headshots for use on adoption sites and across social media. 

“People have to be able to envision a rescue dog as a pet,” the photographer says. With her resources – professional lighting and staging equipment used in her client shoots – Huber is able to communicate a rescue dog’s unique personality. 

“I just love dogs as a subject,” Huber says. “When you isolate their faces, they’re so striking!” Her close up photos freeze her subjects in time, offering a high resolution snapshot of each future adoptee. 

Lulu’s final headshot to be used in her adoption process. Photo courtesy of Sara Huber

Her stunning portraits don’t come out this way by accident, either. Huber balances her highly technical lighting and camera knowledge with a heightened understanding of canine behavior. 

Her skills are especially important for photographing black dogs, which are adopted less often than other dogs. Their black fur poses a unique challenge for rescues; their coats can’t be properly captured by cell phone cameras, and demand a pro’s expert equipment. 

Huber’s repeated posing and reposing (often with the help of peanut butter and squeaky toys) allows potential adoptive families to see each dog for who they are. And with support from local businesses, Huber can devote more of her time towards her important free shoot days. 

Sara Huber can be contacted on her website (pawprintstudioct.com) and via Instagram and Facebook (@pawprintstudioct). All inquiries about supporting the Rescue Photoshoot Sponsor program are welcome, she said.

Like what you see here? Click here to subscribe to We-Ha’s newsletter so you’ll always be in the know about what’s happening in West Hartford! Click the blue button below to become a supporter of We-Ha.com and our efforts to continue producing quality journalism.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Cody Stampede Launched Click Thompson’s Career As Top Rodeo…

Cody Stampede Launched Click Thompson’s Career As Top Rodeo…

CODY — Two-time National Finals Rodeo Photographer of the Year Christopher “Click” Thompson has returned to this legendary Western Wyoming town that helped launch a rodeo photography career that has exceeded even his own wildest dreams.

Thompson returned last week to shoot the Cody Stampede Rodeo.

While he was here, he took time to give a little something back to the town that helped him get his start by hosting an exclusive photography seminar for rodeo shutterbugs.

Thompson has captured artistic, gritty shots from hundreds of rodeos, and he’s a regular at some of the best rodeos in the world. That includes Cheyenne Frontier Days and the Cody Stampede, as well as the Calgary Stampede and the Pendleton Roundup.

“It’s a surreal moment being back here,” Thompson told Cowboy State Daily. “Five years later, the resume looks quite a bit different than it did then.”

Then, Thompson was flat broke. He barely had enough money to buy a camping tent, and he wasn’t exactly sure how he was going afford gas to get back home to Texas.

He needed to shoot five Professional Rodeo Cowboys Association (PRCA) rodeos to become a card-carrying photographer on the circuit. A friend of his, who was the main photographer at the Cody Nite Rodeo and the Stampede Rodeo, invited him to come out and work with him to complete that task.

He’d been looking at a cheap hotel in the area, but it seemed pretty sketch. His friend suggested camping instead.

“I had never camped before,” Thompson said. “But they had their RV here at the Ponderosa campgrounds, and you can tent camp there as well. I”m like, ‘Well it saves me money, so why not?’”

His friend did a lot of work at the time for Coleman, an outdoor outfitters company, so they went to Walmart to buy Coleman camping gear, and Thompson placed his tent at the bottom of the hill at the campground, so it would make a cool photography shot.

“I was right by the river,” Thompson recalled. “And there were some 4H kids there.”

Thompson realized, watching the 4H kids working on their camps, that he probably didn’t know as much about camping as those youths.

He also had even less money than when he’d landed in Cody.

But there was a shower upstairs and he just had to have faith that all was going to be well. All his needs were being taken care of, somehow some way. All he had to do was concentrate on his best photography while he was here at the Cody Stampede Rodeo.

  • Click Thompson brought an impressive array of lenses and camera bodies to an exclusive seminar for rodeo shutterbugs.
    Click Thompson brought an impressive array of lenses and camera bodies to an exclusive seminar for rodeo shutterbugs. (Renee Jean, Cowboy State Daily)
  • Two-time Rodeo Photographer of the Year Christopher “Click” Thompson watches the action while Carrie Mazelin takes a few photos during a photography workshop with Thompson for rodeo shutterbugs. (Renee Jean, Cowboy State Daily)
  • That rope looked like it was going to land — but looks can be deceiving in rodeo. That's all part of the challenge when it comes to taking great photos at the Cody Stampede Rodeo.
    That rope looked like it was going to land — but looks can be deceiving in rodeo. That’s all part of the challenge when it comes to taking great photos at the Cody Stampede Rodeo. (Renee Jean, Cowboy State Daily)
  • The Cody Stampede Rodeo hosted Two-Time Rodeo Photographer of the Year Christopher “Click” Thompson, who also gave a seminar for rodeo shutterbugs while he was in Cody. (Renee Jean, Cowboy State Daily)

The Check Was In The Mail

Thompson had second-guessed leaving his Department of Defense job to chase photography dreams many times.

The time he spent in Cody was no different. Being flat broke, not knowing exactly how he was going to get back home, was a scary place to be in life.

“I think part of the reason my Plan A was successful was I really didn’t have a Plan B,” he said. “I mean, I knew that I would be OK if it didn’t work out. I knew there were other ways I could go, but I was kind of all in on this deal.”

About the time he was doubting his path the most, his mom called to tell him a check had arrived in the mail for him. It had $150 on it.

“Put that check in the bank,” he told her. “That is how I’m getting home.”

To this day, he doesn’t know where that check came from. Maybe he’d paid too much in taxes. But it didn’t matter. It was the boost he’d needed, right when he’d needed it.

“Every time I would maybe kind of second guess or doubt what I was doing, God would give me some reason, or there would be some sign that like, I’m on the right path,” Thompson said. “This was that moment in Cody.”

Camping in Cody was the first and the last time he ever had to sleep in a tent, Thompson said.

“Now I’m sleeping at the Holiday Inn, and I”m teaching people how to do what I do,” he said.

Home At The Rodeo

For Thompson, Rodeo has been one the most welcoming of environments. That’s part of the reason he fell in love with the sport while he was in Virginia.

A friend had invited him out to take photographs at a rodeo. Thompson arrived without expectations — but was almost immediately hooked.

There was the movement of the bulls — those muscles rippling under the surface, that power in their eyes. Each had a different personality. A personality he could capture with his camera.

They were captivating — and that was before he even saw bull-riding.

“Then a downpour came and here I am standing under a tent with a bunch of people I don’t know,” he said. “And it’s just a bunch of cowboys.”

But Thompson had this feeling that somehow he’d come home. This was where he was meant to be.

After that, he’d do a rodeo as often as he could. He was obsessed.

The bulls were raw power. Forces of nature.

And the cowboys who rode them …

He couldn’t get enough.

Before too long, Thompson’s photos were getting a lot of attention, and he got a couple of rodeo gigs over the course of a year, which made around $20,000.

“I thought if I could just string a couple more of these events together and do a few things on the side, maybe I might have something here,” he said. “I mean, it ain’t going to be the luxury lifestyle, but the freedom and the quality of life is definitely going to change.”

  • Two-time PRCA Rodeo Photographer of the Year Christopher “Click” Thompson shares tips for shooting the Cody Stampede Rodeo. (Renee Jean, Cowboy State Daily)
  • Christopher “Click” Thompson talks about making this photo, an award winner of a cowboy riding a horse that looks like a hurricane. (Renee Jean, Cowboy State Daily)
  • Two-time PRCA Rodeo Photographer of the Year Christopher “Click” Thompson talks about shooting the Cody Stampede Rodeo for an exclusive photography workshop for rodeo shutterbugs. (Renee Jean, Cowboy State Daily)
  • Action is fast at the Cody Stampede Rodeo — even when its during what’s known as “slack.” (Renee Jean, Cowboy State Daily)

That Gold Buckle Feeling

When Thompson shows up for a photography seminar, he brings an impressive array of telephoto and wide angle lenses. There’s at least 16 on the table and that’s not even all of the lenses he has.

But what really makes the difference is not the equipment. It’s his mindset.

He’s going to change his location. He’s going to think like the bulls and the cowboys, so he can anticipate where the action that makes the best photo is likeliest to happen.

He also knows the cowboys well. He knows their habits. He knows which ones are going to jump off the horse and fly through the air and which ones are going to take that moment to pump their fist when they taste victory in the dusty air.

The technical understanding of his equipment is important, but it’s the emotions he captures that makes a photographer of the year.

It’s an approach he freely shares with other rodeo shutterbugs during his seminars. It’s his way of giving back what he feels the universe of rodeo has given to him.

Being named PRCA Photographer of the Year for two years in a row was an awesome feeling, Thompson said.

But what really gives him the gold buckle feeling is knowing that he isn’t a Ferrari in first gear any more.

He’s in full throttle, chasing after his dreams, and, in doing that, he’s found his place in the world.

“No day is the same,” he said. “Each day is different. And there’s always new opportunities and I get to share what I do with people. So that’s pretty cool.”

Renée Jean can be reached at renee@cowboystatedaily.com.

In case you missed it

Alaskan Brown Bear Brings Her Cubs Right Up To Group Of Photographers

Alaskan Brown Bear Brings Her Cubs Right Up To Group Of Photographers

A once in a lifetime opportunity for these photographers.

As wildlife photographers, they most often spend their time positioning themselves to be unseen and unheard so they can capture the perfect shot of animals in the wild doing their everyday tasks. While I personally would never have the patience to make it in this field, and I am clumsier than a bull in a China shop, I would constantly be disrupting the perfect shot.

However, those in the field are experts at their craft and capture many moments from the wild that humans would never see without their talent.

With a job this hard, when the perfect shot comes to you, they must be in awe. And that is precisely what happened when this group of photographers were stunned to see a momma bear leading her cubs right toward the group of photographers.

An Alaskan wildlife photographer, Casey Cooper, led a group of photographers when this rare moment happened. Cooper took to TikTok to educate viewers on why the group remained still and quiet during the interaction, as the mom was checking out the group to ensure they would not harm her precious cubs.

“You’re probably wondering what is actually happening here and why this mother brown bear is getting so close to us so let me explain…. My friend Stone_images and I are longtime professional bear guides on the bear coast in Alaska. Scott has spent almost every summer camping in bear country with these bears for well over a decade and watched them grow from a young age, including this mother bear.

The safer option in this moment was to keep everyone close and just let her calmly pass by us. This is Alaska and in specific locations the bears have more than enough natural food for them so they take almost no interest in mammals or humans especially when they are habituated like this sow. (This would never happen in other regions of Alaska or really anywhere else in the world) but quickly getting up and moving under these circumstances would have made her uncomfortable and could have changed the bear’s behavior.

Also to this bear that is very used to people being around she has learned that humans are not a threat to her or her cubs so her body language is very relaxed. This is why it’s so important for you to do your research when choosing people to take you into bear country who can read bears and offer safe encounters.”

The informative information was wrapped up with sharing that brown bears in this part of Alaska are very tolerant of humans, but you should never let a group of brown bears get that close to you in the wild.

They are at the top of the food chain in the wild for a reason.

@cooperlost Brown bear brings her cubs right by photography group😳 You’re probably wondering what is actually happening here and why this mother brown bear is getting so close to us so let me explain…. My friend @stone_images and I are longtime professional bear guides on the bear coast in Alaska. Scott has spent almost every summer camping in bear country with these bears for well over a decade and watched them grow from a young age, including this mother bear. The safer option in this moment was to keep everyone close and just let her calmly pass by us. This is Alaska and in specific locations the bears have more than enough natural food for them so they take almost no interest in mammals or humans especially when they are habituated like this sow. (This would never happen in other regions of Alaska or really anywhere else in the world) but quickly getting up and moving under these circumstances would have made her uncomfortable and could have changed the bears behavior. Also to this bear that is very used to people being around she has learned that humans are not a threat to her or her cubs so her body language is very relaxed. This is why it’s so important for you to do your research when choosing people to take you into bear country who can read bears and offer safe encounters. Dont ever let bears get close to you or approach them. They are the apex animal on almost every continent and they will attack. The brown bears in the area this clip is taken are extremely well fed and tolerant of human presence. #brownbear #alaskalife #bearsofinstagram #apexpredator ♬ original sound – Casey Cooper

While many of the photographers remained as still as possible, a few in the group moved around, which made those in the comments extremely nervous.

“I don’t need to be faster than the bears; I just need to be faster than that first row of photographers, lol.”

“Too close, dude.”

“The woman who keeps moving!”

“No photos are worth my life.”

“Nope. Nope. The bears will bear. They’re glorious- do not get me wrong- but they’re gonna bear!!”

While these photographers were safe and all turned out well, I can’t blame the public for expressing their concern. I’d be shaking with tears running down my face if I were in this situation.

The end result, though…breathtaking.

@cooperlost Intense bear fight broke out extremely close to us 😳 #bearsoftiktok #katmainationalpark #brownbears #bearfight #grizzlybear ♬ original sound – Casey Cooper

Bloodied face, fist raised in defiance: how this image may win Trump the US presidency

Bloodied face, fist raised in defiance: how this image may win Trump the US presidency

The Stars and Stripes flutters in the background as a bloody-faced Donald Trump raises a fist in defiance and calls on his supporters to fight on. 

The image of Trump seconds after surviving an assassination attempt is one of those photographs of obvious and immediate power.

He could not have looked more like an American hero if he tried. If he wins the election in November, it will likely be considered one of a handful of photographs that altered the course of the country’s history.

It is a product of world-class photojournalism – and also, perhaps, of Trump’s innate political instincts.

About a minute after Trump took cover from a gunman’s bullets, the Secret Service agents shielding his body decided to move him to safety. “We’re clear, let’s move,” they were heard saying before raising the former president to his feet.

But Trump told them to “wait”. Before being ushered away, he turned to the crowd, raised his fist and mouthed what looked, to lip readers, like the word “fight”.

A bullet whistles towards Trump's ear


A bullet whistles towards Trump’s ear


Credit: DOUG MILLS/NEW YORK TIMES

Trump, of course, is a showman. Those who know him describe how he is constantly thinking about how he will appear at a given moment. Whether he was acting on pure instinct, or he had time in those 60 seconds on the ground to actually think through a photo opportunity, it paid off.

The Telegraph ran with a shot by the AP’s Evan Vucci, standing below Trump. But there are no shortage of variations on the theme. Anna Money of Getty and Brendan McDermid of Reuters captured the moment from other angles. 

The New York Times’ Doug Mills even captured what appears to be the bullet in flight after it clipped Trump’s right ear.

Trump is rushed offstage after being shot


Trump is rushed offstage after being shot


Credit: ANNA MONEY/GETTY

By Sunday afternoon, Chinese entrepreneurs had already started selling souvenir T-shirts emblazoned with the photograph

“We put the T-shirts on Taobao as soon as we saw the news about the shooting, though we hadn’t even printed them, and within three hours we saw more than 2,000 orders from both China and the US,” Li Jinwei, one of the online sellers to start selling such T-shirts on the Taobao e-commerce platform, told the South China Morning Post.

Mr Vucci, an AP veteran who memorably photographed a protester throwing a shoe at George W Bush in Iraq, described how experience as a war photographer helped him in capturing the historic moment on Saturday.

“Over my left shoulder, I heard pops, and I knew immediately what it was, and I just kind of went into work mode,” he told Kasie Hunt on CNN This Morning.

“That experience does help, trying to stay calm and understand you have a job to do.”

“As a still photographer, I don’t get a second chance,” he said.

It is too early to tell how their images will change the campaign. But they will certainly be compared to a handful of other iconic American photographs.

The obvious historic parallel should be the blurry image of Jackie Kennedy clambering out of the back of the presidential limousine after her husband, John F Kennedy, had been shot dead next to her in November 1963. Or the gaggle of suited secret servicemen leaping on John Hinckley after he shot Ronald Reagan in 1981.

But it is another image that instantly springs to mind.

US Marines raise the Stars and Stripes over Iwo Jima in 1945


US Marines raise the Stars and Stripes over Iwo Jima in 1945


Credit: JOE ROSENTHAL/AP

The Secret Service agents, braced against Trump as they try to usher him away while shielding him, bear an unmistakable resemblance in posture, movement, and unity of purpose as the six US Marines who raised the Stars and Stripes over Iwo Jima in 1945.

Joe Rosenthal’s famous picture is, like Mr Vucci’s from Saturday, an action shot capturing both a split second of frantic activity and a major moment in history. And of course there is the flag itself, fluttering in proud defiance of an attack on American democracy.

It is quite literally the broad stripes and bright stars still gallantly streaming. There could not be anything more American.

The outcome of the Second World War was not in doubt when Iwo Jima fell. But other photographs have been credited with changing the course of events.

Harrowing: the image of nine-year old Phan Thị Kim Phúc


Harrowing: the image of nine-year old Phan Thị Kim Phúc


Credit: NICK UT/AP

Perhaps the most famous came in June 1972, when the New York Times published on its front page a black and white photograph of a naked Vietnamese girl fleeing an air strike that mistakenly hit civilians.

Nick Ut’s photograph of nine-year old Phan Thị Kim Phúc was such an indictment of the use of napalm that President Richard Nixon even mused privately whether it had been staged to turn opinion against the war. It had not.

Muhammad Ali stands triumphant after beating Sonny Liston


Muhammad Ali stands triumphant after beating Sonny Liston


Credit: NEIL LEIFIER/GETTY

It is unclear whether that picture did help end the war, which ran on for another three years. The American public had already largely turned against the conflict by the time it appeared. But it is considered one of the most politically consequential photographs to date.

Because America is so young, much of its history has been caught on camera: Neil Armstrong’s photograph of Buzz Aldrin walking on the moon in 1969; Muhammad Ali standing over a defeated Sonny Liston;  Tommie Smith and John Carlos making the Black Power salute at the Mexico City Olympics.

Neil Armstrong's photograph of Buzz Aldrin walking on the moon


Neil Armstrong’s photograph of Buzz Aldrin walking on the moon


Credit: NASA/PA

The Twin Towers billowing smoke on September 11, the plethora of images from the rubble after they fell, and three firefighters raising the flag at ground zero afterwards, a hooded prisoner in Abu Ghraib prison, Barack Obama watching the killing of Osama bin Laden.

The image of Trump is so perfectly formed that some, like president Nixon or conspiracy theorists who believe the moon landings were faked, might be tempted to wonder if it is genuine.

Former US president Barack Obama and his national security team in the White House Situation Room


Barack Obama, the former US president, and his national security team in the White House Situation Room


Credit: PETE SOUZA/AFP

But that would be to misunderstand the nature of photojournalism in moments of chaos and danger.

As Rosenthal, who nearly missed the moment on Iwo Jima, and had to press the shutter without time to look through the viewfinder, put it: “When you take a picture like that, you don’t come away saying you got a great shot. You don’t know.”

Can Doug Mill’s photo of a bullet and President Trump be real? Yes. Here’s how…

Can Doug Mill’s photo of a bullet and President Trump be real? Yes. Here’s how…

This morning the world is looking at a picture by Doug Mills, a New York Times photographer, which appears to show a blurred trail of a bullet having passed President Trump or clipped his ear.

Many will be asking themselves “Is it possible to take a picture of a bullet in flight?” The short answer is “Yes”, so there is no reason to assume Mills image is a fake.

Taking a photograph of a bullet has been done before, but typically it’s done in controlled circumstances – Sweedish photographer captured a picture of biathlete Hanna Öberg, using a Nikon Z 9 which shows the bullet leaving the muzzle of a rifle.

Strand used a “spray and pray” approach with the camera’s 120fps stills mode and a shutter of 1/32,000sec, but it was still the result of a good amount of timing and practice getting to grips with the timing of the athlete’s firing so the bullet was fired while the image buffer had from to write to.

At 1/32,000sec, however, the ‘frozen bullet’ – despite some motion blur – is more or less visible for its shape….

Mills, being a professional, will also no doubt have used his burst and full image buffer to capture as many images as possible the moment it became clear something was happening.

With the bright conditions and the camera closely focussed on the President, a nearby passing bullet would be in sharp focus if passing close enough.

The only remaining question as to whether a blur is visible is how fast it was going compared to the shutter speed.

The shooter, identified by the FBI as Thomas Matthew Crooks, used “an AR-style rifle” – which would send a bullet at around 3000ft/sec as it leaves the gun.

A bullet loses speed as it flies, and the shooter was around 600ft from the former President. 

According to Politiko, Mills was taking photos with “a Sony camera capable of up to 30fps and 1/8000sec” (though they don’t say which one or what setting he was using). 

Mills is known to have spoken about why he switched to the Sony a9 (from Canon) in the past (the interview is on the Sony site). We now think he’s using a Sony A9iii.

In that case he might have been shooting at 1/8000sec (it was a bright day), but the camera offers up to 120fps bursts and 1/80,000 sec, not that anyone would choose that setting unless planning for a bullet!

Mills has since described the event to the New York Times (subscription required for full story).

The point being that the shutter speeds and ballistic math seems to suggest there is no reason why, in this photo, we’re not seeing air displacement from a passing bullet – though since 5 shots were fired it’s not clear if it’s the one which clipped Trump’s ear.

One might expect to see debris in that case, and according to Politiko again, Michael Harrigan, an FBI retiree agress that is could be a bullet but “the angle seems a little low” to be the one to go through the ear.

For more reading, check our guide to the best Sony cameras.