‘We were both shocked that the photo was ever taken’: the collectors who assembled a trove of early vernacular photos of men in love

‘We were both shocked that the photo was ever taken’: the collectors who assembled a trove of early vernacular photos of men in love

On an ordinary Sunday 20 years ago, Hugh Nini and Neal Treadwell went to a local antique mall they’d been to many times before. While browsing, Treadwell spotted a box filled with old photographs and, as he flipped through, he found a snapshot of two men in a romantic embrace, dated 1927. “At the time we were both shocked that the photo was ever taken,” says Nini, a former ballet academy director, “much less survived 73 years to end up in our hands, in Dallas, Texas.” The couple thought they’d never find another antique photo of men in love.

And then they did, almost a year later. “When we found the first, we had no expectation there would ever be a second,” Nini says. They have since found photographs of male couples in formats dating to the beginning of the medium—daguerreotypes, glass negatives, cabinet cards, tintypes and photo booth snapshots—at flea markets, estate sales and online marketplaces, all taken during an era when same-sex marriage was illegal. It was only when they had amassed around 300 photographs that Nini and Treadwell realised it was a collection. It now numbers more than 4,000 vernacular photos dating from between the 1850s and 1950s, sourced from 36 different countries.

Loving: They Love Each Other, Musée d’art et d’Histoire Geneve (MAH). Courtesy of Hugh Nini and Neal Treadwell.

The exhibition Loving: They Love Each Other(until 24 September) at the Musée d’art et d’histoire (MAH) in Geneva, Switzerland, publicly debuts a selection of 400 images from their trove. Inspired by the book about their collection published in 2020 (Loving: A Photographic History of Men in Love 1850-1950, Five Continents Editions), the exhibition contains almost every photograph from the book plus 80 that Nini and Treadwell collected after its release.

“In these pictures it’s fantastic the number of different stories it could activate,” says MAH director Marc-Olivier Wahler of Loving as a whole, and also a 1951 photograph of two soldiers sitting on a bench. “You wonder, they’re in the army and are they really together? Then suddenly you see the entangled feet. And all these possible stories—what happened to them, what happened to this photograph? Where was it found? It’s endless.”

Loving: They Love Each Other, Musée d’art et d’Histoire Geneve (MAH). Courtesy of Hugh Nini and Neal Treadwell.

Loving also includes newly commissioned artwork by Swiss photographer Walter Pfeiffer, known for his playfully erotic portraits of male models. Pfeiffer chose snapshots from Nini and Treadwell’s collection and then colorised and enlarged them, layering a contemporary filter on the vintage images. Two rare black-and-white videos by conceptual artist Urs Lüthi will also be screened together with the exhibition.

In contrast to these two established Swiss artists, most of the photographers and sitters in the photographs are anonymous. An outlier is an early 20th century portrait that may be of Bloomsbury circle artist Duncan Grant and poet Rupert Brooke. Otherwise, the men in the photographs are unnamed.

Loving: They Love Each Other, Musée d’art et d’Histoire Geneve (MAH). Courtesy of Hugh Nini and Neal Treadwell.

Apart from some photo booth snapshots (generated by a machine) and an early selfie of a couple in a mirror, the authors of the images are also unknown. With many of the photographs in the collection taken at a time before at-home cameras were readily available, the understanding is that couples used photographers who they felt comfortable approaching to help produce visual testimony of their loving relationships. Few 19th-century photographers are known to have taken portraits of same-sex couples, with New York-based Alice Austen being one of them. This collection proves there were many uncredited others.

As private collectors, Nini and Treadwell had the freedom to preserve something outside of the institutional mainstream and inspire new research. “We felt [it] was our obligation to keep these photographs. To keep them safe,” says Treadwell, who works in the cosmetics industry. “Our goal is to continue to have museum exhibitions wherever we can that will propel us into telling this story and sharing the history that love is love. Love has been around forever.”

Loving: They Love Each Other, Musée d’art et d’Histoire Geneve (MAH). Courtesy of Hugh Nini and Neal Treadwell.

Chimp cuddles and clever coyotes: the 10th BigPicture Natural World photography competition

Chimp cuddles and clever coyotes: the 10th BigPicture Natural World photography competition
image

Many forests in Jasper National Park in Alberta, Canada, benefit from naturally occurring, low-intensity wildfires. Without fire, trees grow unnaturally dense, and dead logs accumulate on the forest floor. This timber can collide with hotter, drier conditions and cause explosively large wildfires. Now forest managers are trying to reverse a century of misguided management by igniting controlled burns. The landscape may look different, but as this haunting image of a burned spruce forest shows, they can be equally captivating.

Hip-hop artists in India call out caste discrimination

Hip-hop artists in India call out caste discrimination
image

When Harish Kamble, 29, was in his late teens, he said, he had a humiliating encounter that stuck with him.

He had gone to collect a document from someone’s house in his village in southern India. The man wasn’t home so his wife asked Kamble to take a seat and wait.

After the man arrived, he was furious to see Kamble, who is from a so-called lower caste, or social class, in his house. Kamble said he’s never been able to shake it off.

“Till today, when I go somewhere, I think twice before going to anyone’s house. See that childhood trauma you carry with you all the time,” he said.

Kamble also remembers his grandparents telling him how their land was taken away by people from the dominant caste. The injustices that his family and others from his community faced became the subject of a lot of his poetry and later, rap lyrics.

In India, a new wave of Dalit artists like Kamble are using hip-hop to stand up to one of the world’s oldest forms of discrimination: caste, similar to how Black rappers in the US began channeling decades ago to call out prejudice and injustice.

But this wasn’t the kind of hip-hop these artists grew up listening to. In Indian pop culture, hip-hop is associated with misogyny. The popular rappers in the country mostly sing about partying, drinking and chasing after girls.

Kamble said that he used to think that’s all hip-hop was about.

“When I got to know that hip-hop is something that was started for a good cause back in the ’70s, it was all started in America, then it was very relevant for my experiences too,” he said.

Since then, he said, he’s discovered a lot of American hip-hop artists — from Tupac to Kendrick Lamar.

Kamble’s rap is a continuation of his family’s tradition of musical activism. His grandfather used to sing “Bhim geet,” songs about B. R. Ambedkar who fought for Dalit rights and wrote India’s constitution.

In his 2019 song called “Jaati,” which means “caste” in his native Kannada language, Kamble compares caste-based thought to a tsunami.

“Where is my place in this great country?” he asks. 

Vipin Tatad, who grew up in a slum in the western state of Maharashtra, said that he writes about what he sees his community go through on a daily basis. His latest song includes verses about how scores of Dalits die each year while manually cleaning sewers, suffocated by the toxic gases inside.

The words go: “Those drains and gutters, why do we have to clean them?/Do we own contracts to clean them/Those gutters are filled with toxic gases/Hydrogen sulfide and poisonous methane/One fatal breath ends our life/We’re dying and you say, “let them die/Is there anything even left to talk?”

If you want to get your message across to young people, you have to rap, Tatad said.

And he is getting attention.

He helped create the theme song of a Netflix documentary about a serial rapist who was murdered in a courtroom in 2004 by dozens of lower-caste women, his victims. Tatad has also written a rap song for a Bollywood movie starring superstar Amitabh Bachchan.

But his journey, he said, has been full of struggles. He’s been stopped in the middle of performances. He and his bandmates have to produce songs on their own, which is expensive. The income from gigs is never enough, he said.

“The mainstream music industry doesn’t have space for us,” Tatad said.

Likewise, most of the listeners of anti-caste rap are from the same communities as the artists. Mainstream audiences are far from accepting anti-caste rap, said Brahma Prakash, assistant professor in the school of arts and aesthetics at Delhi’s Jawaharlal Nehru University.

He said that Indian listeners want music that soothes or heals you. But “rap is to disturb you,” he said. “I don’t think Indian consciousness in a larger way is ready for these kinds of songs.”

For now, anti-caste rappers are carving their own space — on social media. Top artists like Arivu have more than 1.5 million monthly listeners on Spotify. Some of Tatad’s songs have more than 200,000 views on YouTube. But he doesn’t think of his music as a career — it’s more of a responsibility, he said.

“If we don’t raise our voices, we will continue to be exploited,” Tatad said. “Until society treats us equally, we will carry on his musical struggle against caste.”

City Life Org – The Seaport Unveils Summer Arts Showcase with New Photography Exhibitions El Camino: Stories of Migration, Hip Hop at 50 and More

City Life Org – The Seaport Unveils Summer Arts Showcase with New Photography Exhibitions El Camino: Stories of Migration, Hip Hop at 50 and More

Salt n Pepa, Lower East Side NYC 1986 ©Janette Beckman

Seaport Arts summer lineup kicks off with free exhibits, outdoor sculptures, augmented-reality digital galleries and more on display throughout the Lower Manhattan waterfront neighborhood

The Howard Hughes Corporation® (HHC) announced its Seaport Arts lineup for the 2023 summer season, kicked off the showcase with the unveiling of the El Camino: Stories of Migration photo series, part of Lower Manhattan Cultural Council’s River To River festival, and Photoville’s Hip Hop at 50. With a wide variety of installations on display throughout the year, Seaport Arts presents curated works designed to intrigue and inspire, from intricate outdoor sculptures to augmented reality digital art, positioning the Lower Manhattan neighborhood as a destination for arts and culture.

On June 9th, El Camino: Stories of Migration took center stage at the Seaport. Featuring an exhibition of photographs and stories by the multimedia and archival project Nuevayorkinos, El Camino: Stories of Migration was installed in the window galleries of the Seaport’s Fulton Market Building along Front Street. The exhibition celebrates the stories of Caribbean and Latin American immigration by portraying the visual narratives of the struggle and joy of finding a new home and community in New York City. In collaboration with the Lower Manhattan Cultural Council’s annual River To River Festival, El Camino will be on display at the Seaport now through June 30th.

Also in June, the beloved public photography festival Photoville will display Hip Hop at 50 by Janette Beckman on the windows at the corner of Fulton and Front Street. Known for her work in the 80’s with hip-hop, Beckman is an influential documentarian with an eye for the cutting-edge in urban culture. To celebrate the 50th anniversary of Hip Hop in NYC, her work will be displayed from early June through October.

The Seaport also welcomes SuperRare, a leading marketplace for unique digital art, for a two-month-long pop-up at the 0x.17 Gallery on Pier 17. A community-focused NFT gallery showcasing digital works of art, SuperRare at the 0x.17 Gallery will host four curated exhibitions featuring works from over 20 renowned digital artists. The exhibitions will provide a captivating look at a wide variety of themes and concepts found in digital art. Visitors will be able to enjoy the immersive pieces adorning the 0x.17 Gallery until the end of July.

From June 16th through July 2nd, the New Museum’s cultural incubator NEW INC, in collaboration with Science Sandbox, will display a Creative Science Showcase at the Heineken Riverdeck on Pier 17 as part of NEW INC’s art and technology festival DEMO2023. The artists, researchers, and scientists in the Creative Science track at NEW INC look at the evolving relationships between the species inhabiting the earth and the effects of the ongoing climate crisis. The showcase features outdoor sculptures, augmented reality videos, a lighting installation and other scientific and fictional works. With pieces set against the stunning backdrop of the Manhattan skyline, the Creative Science Showcase brings a vibrant, one-of-a-kind exhibition to the Seaport.

For more information on Seaport Arts, please visit https://theseaport.nyc/arts/.

In addition to Seaport Arts, the neighborhood welcomes the return of its four popular summer series, Seaport Sounds, Seaport Fit, Seaport Cinema and Seaport Kids. With renowned dining and entertainment experiences, cultural celebrations, pop-up exhibits and more, the Seaport offers events throughout the summer. For more information on programming at the Seaport, please visit https://theseaport.nyc/neighborhood-events/.

About The Seaport

The Seaport is New York City’s original neighborhood, a maritime hub of history located along the East River in Lower Manhattan, with iconic waterfront views of the Brooklyn Bridge and the city skyline. It serves as a vibrant home to residents and a global destination for travelers, offering more than 450,000 square feet of entertainment, dining, and cultural experiences.

Home to independent businesses, the historic South Street Seaport Museum, the entertainment hub Pier 17®, and the newly restored Tin Building—a 53,000-square-foot culinary destination curated by Jean-Georges, the Seaport is an epicenter of culture. With support from Chase® and Heineken®—founding partners in The Howard Hughes Corporation’s revitalization of the Seaport—the neighborhood celebrates emerging and resident artists, local organizations, and community connectivity through its curated seasonal programming. Visit www.TheSeaport.nyc for more.

About The Howard Hughes Corporation®

The Howard Hughes Corporation owns, manages and develops commercial, residential and mixed-use real estate throughout the U.S. Its award-winning assets include the country’s preeminent portfolio of master planned cities and communities, as well as operating properties and development opportunities including: the Seaport in New York City; Downtown Columbia®  in Maryland; The Woodlands®, The Woodlands Hills®, and Bridgeland® in the Greater Houston, Texas area; Summerlin® in Las Vegas; Ward Village® in Honolulu, Hawai‘i; and Teravalis™ in the Greater Phoenix, Arizona area. The Howard Hughes Corporation’s portfolio is strategically positioned to meet and accelerate development based on market demand, resulting in one of the strongest real estate platforms in the country.

Today’s Photo from Ted Grussing Photography: Sometimes you do and sometimes…

Today’s Photo from Ted Grussing Photography: Sometimes you do and sometimes…

… life is filled with opportunities and choices … sometimes you get it right and sometimes not so much. Spent most of the day catching with friends I have not talked to in a while and near the end of day I headed up to the Rainbow Trout Farm in the canyon … a very quiet place at end of day and important to a few herons and hawks that grab a meal there.

Above is a great blue heron who scored a fine meal and below one that didn’t … kinda like us when we go fishing, but for us survival is usually not what is at stake!

End of the week for me … have a beautiful day and weekend. The plan is to be back Monday morning having had more days filled with beauty and joy … always a choice how we experience each day!

Smiles,

Ted

Filled with dreams and songs and love, I wander
afield.

Meditation, softened by the peaceful lands of grain and
the illimitable blue sea overhead, draws my heart to
my lips as one whose talent is in song.

I yield to the thousand felicities of this transport, like a
child led by his father’s hand; and no questions darken
this day of my content.

Afield by Max Ehrmann

###

photo_tedgrussingThe easiest way to reach Mr. Grussing is by email: ted@tedgrussing.com

In addition to sales of photographs already taken Ted does special shoots for patrons on request and also does air-to-air photography for those who want photographs of their airplanes in flight. All special photographic sessions are billed on an hourly basis.

Ted also does one-on-one workshops for those interested in learning the techniques he uses.  By special arrangement Ted will do one-on-one aerial photography workshops which will include actual photo sessions in the air.

More about Ted Grussing


Healing Paws

Healing Paws

This is an advertisement

Joyful photographs of Scouts show a sense of belonging and freedom

Joyful photographs of Scouts show a sense of belonging and freedom


CNN
 — 

In sun-dappled scenes shot across the German countryside, boys and girls in navy Scout uniforms hike through the woods, pitch tents and lay on the grass under open skies. They wear striped kerchiefs and frayed patches of their national flag. In quiet moments, girls clasp hands and recline against one another; one Scout erupts in laughter as she holds another’s foot to be mercilessly tickled.

Taken by the German photographer Stephan Lucka, the images, “Das Gefühl, das nur wir kennen,” or “The feeling, that only we know,” are saturated in coming-of-age nostalgia for anyone who relished in a sense of freedom in the outdoors.

For Lucka, who was first a Scout in the 1990s in Bad Salzuflen, a town in Western Germany, and later a troop leader there, the project served as both a homecoming and a way to better understand those formative years. Having photographed Scout groups around the country beginning in 2015, he published the series as a book late in 2022.

Stephan_Lucka_Das_Gefühl_das_nur_wir_kennen_Pressefoto-2982

“Sometimes with life you can only understand it backwards,” Lucka said in a video interview. “In a simple way, I wanted to return to that time that was part of my youth… and try to understand what this time meant to me.”

“I realized that (Scouting) shaped me in an important way,” he added.

Nature and nurture

Though Lucka said some aspects of Scouting have adapted to new technology since he was young — today, troops shoot social media content and use Slack to organize themselves, for example — he found the reasons why young people join are largely the same: to foster “this feeling of connection” to others and to nature, as he described it.

“With the Scouts I am more on my own, I have to be more independent… but I also feel part of something big,” said 13-year-old Jette, whose Scout nickname is Tonks, in a translated interview from the book. “The fact that you are independent but also part of a community at the same time is somehow paradoxical to me… It is a feeling of freedom and belonging in equal measure.”

Stephan_Lucka_Das_Gefühl_das_nur_wir_kennen_Pressefoto-3561
Stephan_Lucka_Das_Gefühl_das_nur_wir_kennen_Pressefoto-7769

One of Lucka’s favorite images is one of the earliest he took, of two teenage girls laying entwined on a purple mat on the grass while out camping in the woods, eyes closed and hair fanning out beside them.

“It was just one exposure, and then I went away because I didn’t want to disturb them,” Lucka recalled. “But to me, there’s this intimacy that always resonated.”

Wandering the path

In Germany, the Scouting movement took off in 1909, a year after the publication of British Army officer Robert Baden-Powell’s book “Scouting for Boys,” which is the framework for the organization (now present in 216 countries). But at that time, the country’s youth were already experiencing a revolution that brought them into nature. The movement, called Wandervogel, or “wandering bird,” began in Berlin, and saw children and teens rebel against industrialization by hiking and adventuring in groups, rejecting city lifestyles and materialism. Under Nazi Germany, Wandervogel and Scouting groups were banned; Scouting returned to West Germany following the war, but not to East Germany until 1990 when the country was reunified.

In German, scouts are called “pfadfinder,” meaning “pathfinder,” which Lucka pointed out as he recalled an anxiety-inducing time when, as a troop leader, he nearly couldn’t find the way back to camp for his group.

Stephan_Lucka_Das_Gefühl_das_nur_wir_kennen_Pressefoto-1951

“I got lost — I had a map and a compass, but I couldn’t actually identify where I was,” he said with a laugh. “It was kind of strange situation.”

How did he get back on track? Thanks to Scouts guidance that had been ingrained in him when he was young: Seek higher ground for a better perspective. So he climbed a tree, identified a point that was recognizable, and led his troop there using his compass.

“I found the Scout solution: When you get lost, try to get a better view,” he paused. “And this is a bit metaphoric for life.”

Today, Scouting in Germany emphasizes hiking, camping and practical skills, as well as the creative arts, Lucka said. He also credits the community with helping him to develop social skills and gain confidence in himself. At the end of his book, he rewinds time with a collection of personal snaps from his Scouting days: a portrait of a young Lucka with sunglasses and long, curly hair on a night he remembers falling in love; another of his troop on a bus trip from France, triumphantly holding a baguette. Ultimately, he thinks “Das Gefühl, das nur wir kennen” is “a story about freedom,” but also one of acceptance, showing a community where many have found a “safe space” to be themselves.

In its cultivation of this environment, and kinship, “The Scouts (could be) a model for how to treat each other in a decent way,” he added.

Das Gefühl, das nur wir kennen” is available now.