About

Posts by :

The camera never lies? Creator of AI image rejects prestigious photo award

The camera never lies? Creator of AI image rejects prestigious photo award
image

The winner of a Sony World Photography Award has refused to accept the prize after revealing the winning photo he submitted was created using an artificial intelligence image generator.

The Berlin-based German photographer Boris Eldagsen won the Creative category of the award’s 2023 Open competition, and was garlanded at a ceremony on 13 April in London. The award is considered one of photography’s most prestigious honours.

By entering a computer-generated image to a traditional photography prize, and then subsequently refusing to accept the ensuing award, Eldagsen claims he hopes to “drive debate” about a technology that is poised to dramatically alter how we define and understand photorealist imagery.

Eldagsen’s winning image, Pseudomnesia: The Electrician, was created using DALL-E 2, an image generator developed by OpenAI, the San Francisco-based company that also created the AI chatbot ChatGPT.

In his submission, Eldagsen described the image as “a haunting black-and-white portrait of two women from different generations, reminiscent of the visual language of 1940s family portraits”.

A spokesperson for the award has responded by accusing Eldagsen of “deliberate attempts at misleading us” by entering the competition under a false pretence and with the intention of spurning the award.

The award’s judging panel was aware that Eldagsen’s image was AI-generated and awarded the prize in that knowledge, the spokesperson says.

In previous years, the award’s creative category has traditionally honoured photographs that have challenged the boundaries of a conventional photograph. “The award welcomes various experimental approaches to image making,” the spokesperson tells The Art Newspaper.

Shortly after the prize was announced, Eldagsen appeared without invitation on stage to address the gathered audience. In a spontaneous address, he said AI images are not photographs and therefore should not be considered in competitions designed for camera-based practitioners.

Eldagsen then published a statement on his website in which he accused the competition’s judges of failing to distinguish between a photographic image and a ‘generative’ image created by an AI machine.

“I applied as a cheeky monkey, to find out if the competitions are prepared for AI images to enter,” Eldagsen wrote. “They are not.”

“How many of you knew or suspected that it was AI generated? Something about this doesn’t feel right, does it?” he added. “AI images and photography should not compete with each other in an award like this. They are different entities. AI is not photography. Therefore I will not accept the award.”

Speaking to BBC Radio on 18 April, Eldagsen said of the image: “It looks like a 1940s vintage wet-plate [collodion] photograph.”

Eldagsen used the phrase ‘promptography’ to describe the image, alluding to the way platforms like DALL-E 2 and ChatGPT rely on ”prompts“—specific instructions from a user—to create bespoke imagery or content.

“Promptography is done with prompts. Photography is done with light,” Eldagsen told the BBC. “I think it’s very important to differentiate these [two things] by terms, and then to have an open discussion about this in the photography world. Is the umbrella of photography large enough to say [this type of imagery] is part of it? Because the visual language is the same.”

A spokesperson for the Sony World Photography Awards tells The Art Newspaper: “During our various exchanges with Boris Eldagsen ahead of announcing him as the Creative category winner in the Open competition on 14 March, he had confirmed the ‘co-creation’ of this image using AI. In our correspondence he explained how following ‘two decades of photography, my artistic focus has shifted more to exploring creative possibilities of AI generators’ and further emphasising the image heavily relies on his ‘wealth of photographic knowledge’. As per the rules of the competition, the photographers provide the warranties of their entry.

“The Creative category of the Open competition welcomes various experimental approaches to image making from cyanotypes and rayographs to cutting-edge digital practices.

“As such, following our correspondence with Boris and the warranties he provided, we felt that his entry fulfilled the criteria for this category, and we were supportive of his participation. Additionally, we were looking forward to engaging in a more in-depth discussion on this topic and welcomed Boris’ wish for dialogue by preparing questions for a dedicated Q&A with him for our website.

“As he has now decided to decline his award we have suspended our activities with him and in keeping with his wishes have removed him from the competition. Given his actions and subsequent statement noting his deliberate attempts at misleading us, and therefore invalidating the warranties he provided, we no longer feel we are able to engage in a meaningful and constructive dialogue with him.

“We recognise the importance of this subject and its impact on image-making today. We look forward to further exploring this topic via our various channels and programmes and welcome the conversation around it. While elements of AI practices are relevant in artistic contexts of image-making, the Awards always have been and will continue to be a platform for championing the excellence and skill of photographers and artists working in the medium.”

• The Sony World Photography Awards Exhibition is at Somerset House, London, until 1 May

Flower Magazine founder to share floral expertise at Carnegie Museum of Art

Flower Magazine founder to share floral expertise at Carnegie Museum of Art

Margot Shaw doesn’t buy flower arrangements anymore.

Once a self-confessed “call and order flowers girl,” a watershed moment came when planning her daughter’s wedding. Working alongside the floral and event designer, she became inspired and did an apprenticeship with that creator of beautiful blooms.

Shaw will present her artistry at “On Dec” (Dec is short for decorative arts) on April 27 in the music hall at the Carnegie Museum of Art in Oakland.

It’s hosted by the Women’s Committee, which operates exclusively and promotes the cultural and educational value of the Carnegie Museum of Art. Since its inception in 1957, the committee has funded acquisitions, exhibitions, gallery design, and renovations with cash gifts and contributions of almost $10 million. There is a collection of decorative arts in the museum’s Ailsa Mellon Bruce Galleries, which the committee has provided financial support to for renovation of those galleries.

6097055_web1_sew-womenscommittee-shaw

Courtesy of Beth Hontzas

Margot Shaw, founder of Flower Magazine, will give a presentation at “On Dec” April 27 at the Carnegie Museum of Art in Oakland.

Shaw will share her love of entertaining through a slide show titled “The Magic of Outdoor Living,” at 10 a.m. She will also highlight excerpts from her book, “Living Floral: Entertaining and Decorating with Flowers,” published by Rizzoli New York. A book signing will take place in the music hall rotunda as will a pop up shop from the museum’s gift shop with floral or garden-themed items.

A luncheon will follow in the music hall foyer.

“I have heard her speak before, and she has a lot of enthusiasm,” said Mary Margaret Stamy, of Fox Chapel, luncheon chair. “Margot is passionate about floral design so this should be fun. Even if people aren’t into creating arrangements they will still be able to enjoy her beautiful floral designs.”

A native of Birmingham, Ala., Shaw studied art history at Hollins College in Virginia and interior design at the University of Texas. She founded Flower Magazine, which publishes six times a year.

The event fits with the vision of “On Dec,” a re-imagined and branded lecture-luncheon benefit event, a key fundraiser for the committee. Proceeds benefit the women’s committee’s initiatives as well as the Milton and Sheila Fine Collection Foundation, which will host an exhibition opening Nov. 18.

Margot Curran of Sewickley is chair of the patron party, happening April 26 at the Duquesne Club in Downtown Pittsburgh. Women’s Committee president Jennifer Muse is marketing chair and Barbara Thai is speaker chair.

6097055_web1_sew-womenscommittee

Courtesy of Julia Lynn Photography

One of a floral designed outdoor space by Margot Shaw, founder of Flower Magazine

Curran said this is the time of year people think about fresh flowers and gardens. Shaw will demonstrate how her floral arrangements flow into interior designs and the placement of flowers to complement what people are doing to decorate their homes, especially when they plan to entertain.

“Attending an event like this one can be rejuvenating,” said Curran. “You can see what Margot designs and then you can tell yourself ‘I can do that too.’ It’s like when you go shopping and you see a stylish outfit, and you think that you can coordinate an outfit like that as well. The talk will definitely be inspiring.”

Tickets are $175 for the patron party, $125 for the luncheon and are available online at wccmoa.org.

JoAnne Klimovich Harrop is a Tribune-Review staff writer. You can contact JoAnne by email at jharrop@triblive.com or via Twitter .

Categories:
Fox Chapel Herald | Lifestyles | Art & Museums | Oakland | Pittsburgh | Sewickley Herald

This Amy Amalia Painting in Shanika Hillocks’s Apartment Started as an Instagram Crush

This Amy Amalia Painting in Shanika Hillocks’s Apartment Started as an Instagram Crush

What makes a purchase “worth it”? The answer is different for everybody, so we’re asking some of the coolest, most shopping-savvy people we know—from small-business owners to designers, artists, and actors—to tell us the story behind one of their most prized possessions.

Who?

It’s impossible to deny that Shanika Hillocks knows how to curate a vibe. Her Instagram page, a place of intentional energy and intimate connection, feels like a joyful celebration of authenticity. With a background in food and wine, the marketing and brand consultant takes her home decor seriously, as any veritable vibe curator would. Building her home base in what she describes as a “thoughtfully renovated brownstone in Harlem,” Shanika has even blessed the space with its own hashtag: #SugarHillocks (a clever combination of her name and the historic district of Sugar Hill, bordering Jackie Robinson Park, which she calls home). 

Shanika Hillocks at home in Harlem. 

2018 Michelle Nash

What?

Inspired by what she identifies as “a personal calling to pay attention,” Shanika began to explore her personal relationship to art during the early months of the pandemic. Like the rest of her space, she knew it would have to be intentional, curated, and deeply personal. It was at the opening of Nicole Vassell’s Gallery, a Black-woman-owned gallery in Chelsea, where Shanika met a longtime Instagram connection, Cierra Britton, that would lead to her initial investment in art. 

“A few months later, I was scrolling Instagram and was captivated by a series of posts Cierra had just posted: warm golden yellow, piercing eyes, rich black, and the artist Amy Amalia, tagged,” Shanika shares. As she explored the artist, the connections seemed particularly kismet. Like Shanika, Amy is Guyanese-American and New York–based. “The work in her Black Sun series centers on this idea of self-reflection and soul alchemy, two things that resonate deeply with me,” Shanika explains. Working with oil on cradled wood panel, Amy Amalia’s work feels lifelike and animated. The gravity of the piece was a natural fit with the historic details of her home. 

Factory Works to offer classes on film photography and darkroom practices

Factory Works to offer classes on film photography and darkroom practices

Wiliamsport, Pa. — Factory Works Photo Lab at the Pajama Factory will be offering an introduction to black and white film darkroom photography on Tuesday nights in May.

The classes will take place May 2, 9, 16, 23, and 30 from 6-8 pm.

Instruction will cover the basics of film photography and darkroom practices, from using a camera to processing film and ultimately making a finished print. The cost is $100.

Factory Works will have cameras available for use if you don’t already have your own. The only thing you need to provide is a roll of 35mm Ilford 400 ISO film which can be purchased from Hoyer’s Photo on Washington Blvd in Williamsport. Mention you’re a student of the Photo Lab to ensure you purchase the correct film. All other materials are provided.

If you are interested in attending, email photolab@factoryworks.org to coordinate payment. Upon completion of prepayment, students will receive a coupon for 10% off a film purchase at Hoyer’s Photo.

Keep your news local

Access to independent, local news is important, do you agree?

We work hard to deliver timely, relevant news, for free. 100% of your contribution to NorthcentralPa.com goes directly to helping us cover news and events in the region.

Thank you for saying that local news matters!



How do you make your movie marketing better? Just add the Beastie Boys

How do you make your movie marketing better? Just add the Beastie Boys

Like many, I have been suffering from superhero fatigue.

Not just from Marvel, but across the board.

As much as I have enjoyed some outings, I currently stand with the likes of Denis Villeneuve, Bong Joon-ho and David Fincher, who have all publicly criticized superhero movies and their lather-rinse-repeat templates. The best summation of the current state of affairs came from Fincher. During a recent French interview with Canal Plus, the filmmaker behind Se7en, Fight Club and Zodiac described the ubiquitous genre as “not a sandbox that has a lot of room left for exploring.”

However, something happened that I’m still grappling with. 

I actually got excited about a superhero film again.

It happened when I finally sat down to watch the new trailer for the MCU’s 33rd feature film, The Marvels.

It’s a sequel to 2018’s broadly disappointing Captain Marvel, which introduced Brie Larson as the titular superhero. Other characters in this sequel directed by Nia DaCosta (Little Woods, Candyman) include Iman Vellani as Kamala Khan, from last year’s Disney+ series Ms. Marvel, and Teyonah Parris as Monica Rambeau from the show Wandavision.

This film wasn’t on my radar – hence me putting off watching the trailer. That and it taps into what my current Marvel malaise: the fact you need to have an encyclopaedic knowledge of the previous instalments (including the TV shows) just to figure out what’s going on in an individual storyline. Gone are self-contained stories, replaced by endless call-backs and the need for a brain-melting revision session before each screening. Who has the time or the energy at this point? Just look at this year’s Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania and you’ll see what I mean.

However, The Marvels trailer made me take stock. And while I thought I was back drinking the corporate Kool-Aid, it dawned on me. The reason I got excited wasn’t the promise of finding out how the ever-expanding multiverse narrative the MCU are currently locked into will evolve, but that the sap I am had been duped. 

Well and truly musically duped. Because the choice of song in the trailer sparked excitement.

It’s ‘Intergalactic’ by the Beastie Boys. 

Upon hearing this underrated classic from the equally underrated 1998 album ‘Hello Nasty’, gone was my resistance and my attempts to figure out what was going on with the plot about these three characters teaming up and trying to untangle their powers in space… or something. I just found myself singing along and getting unironically pumped up by the idea of watching a new Marvel adventure. Because of the Beastie Boys.

This got me thinking: Are the Beastie Boys the cheat code to making any marketing push flawless?

It certainly worked for The Marvels, as aside from the objectively promising kitten army scene (which looks delightful – skip to 1.38 in the trailer), the choice of such a tune worked its deceitful magic.

Beyond the fact that the catchy ‘Intergalactic’ is an appropriately titled song for a space adventure, it gives The Marvels some light-hearted and comedic vibes, akin to Guardians of the Galaxy – one of the superior Marvel instalments that had a cracking soundtrack. But it also works on another level, with the usage of the song functioning as a sly call-out to Brie Larson’s detractors.

You see, Larson has incurred the wrath of many a rabid Marvel fan over the years, who have commented that the actor comes off badly in interviews, plays a character that is too powerful to be interesting, and who needs to smile more on screen. Ah yes, that derogatory and perennially sexist mainstay.

Well, when Larson appears in the trailer, the song kicks off with the opening lyrics: “Well, now, don’t you tell me to smile / You stick around I’ll make it worth your while / My number’s beyond what you can dial / Maybe it’s because we’re so versatile”.

Surely that can’t be accidental.

Outstanding work to whoever picked the song, someone who clearly understands and appreciates the art of a good needle drop. The right music played at the right time in a trailer or in a film can elevate the images to iconic status. And as I’ve waxed lyrical previously, keeping your marketing funny means that a potential audience member is more likely to shell out for a ticket knowing that the marketing team have a sense of humour.

I can therefore conclude the following:

A) I’m not as immune to this tactic as I previously thought I was.

B) Much like the sirens singing their songs to sailors to crash them onto the rocks, the inclusion of a Beastie Boys track manages to bypass the critical lobe of those like myself who are fed up with the usual crash-bang-wallop of Marvel films. Not only does any track by the pioneering New York City hip-hop outfit immediately make every movie trailer better, it makes it advertising gold.

Here’s further proof.

Take their 1994 hit ‘Sabotage’.

Beyond being a banger and a timeless rebellion anthem, ‘Sabotage’ been used in countless trailers – from Star Trek Beyond to Minions: The Rise of Gru, and every time, it elevates the promo to greatness.

Not convinced?

Then here’s the incontestable piece of evidence.

Take Solo, the utterly superfluous and dull as dishwater 2018 Star Wars prequel / Han Solo origin story.

Here’s the original trailer:

Hardly inspiring, is it?

Now consider this remix: 

Proof that ‘Sabotage’ is possibly the greatest trailer song of all time.

But why is this track so damn effective?

Well, it manages to spice up otherwise bland trailers with its fail-proof instrumental build up that climaxes with riotous breakdown, driving the pace and visual choreography so that the action seems coordinated with its auditory bombast. The end result is a song that manages to promise less an action-filled flick and more of a blockbuster event.

Other bands can have the same effect – see: the ubiquity of Run The Jewels in trailers from 2017 to 2019, when countless movies from Suburbicon to Booksmart via Good Boys saw marketing teams go gaga for the track ‘Nobody Speak’ by DJ Shadow and Run The Jewels.

However, no band or artist has yet to equal or surpass the galvanizing and seemingly timeless cheat code effect of a Beastie Boys track.

The Marvels hits theatres on 10 November. That trio of superheroes will be hoping their success will be equally Intergalactic. But from the trailer alone, anything’s possible now the Beastie Boys have orchestrated their soundtrack magic once again. 

You stick around I’ll make it worth your while, indeed.

Woman of Distinction 2023: Leslie Pott

Woman of Distinction 2023: Leslie Pott

When you were a child, what did you want to be when you grew up?

I have always liked art. Throughout my life, my parents gave me art supplies and art lessons for my birthdays and Christmas rather than toys or dolls. I thought I wanted to be an art teacher, as this was the closest profession I had seen where art was created and enjoyed. With a business major, journalism minor and MBA, I have been able to realize my joy of creating new things every day in my professional career. Finding fresh approaches to communicating complex business issues and policies is more of an art than a science, so I feel like an artist every day. In my free time, I paint pictures of other people’s dogs to bring joy to others.

What would you do if you didn’t work in healthcare?

I suppose I would enjoy any career as long as I could be creative. I like my boss, I have an impact on other people’s lives and I have fun. Healthcare makes it all the sweeter.

What do you like most about working in healthcare marketing?

Healthcare is a purpose-driven industry and profession. Everyone in this field is passionate about what they do and why they do it. The marketing profession pushes you to think like the customer, to create ideas and messages that reach your audience, you are immediately rewarded or punished for great or poor marketing — and this will never be boring.

What frustrates you most about working in healthcare marketing?

I am frustrated that healthcare is lumped into one category. It is difficult to differentiate when polarizing opinions on pharmaceutical companies are shared by individuals who are also caring for loved ones with access to the highest quality and efficacious medicines. As a spokesperson for the generics industry, I continue to spotlight the role generics and biosimilars play in our healthcare system and in our lives — from reducing out-of-pocket costs and driving increased access to critical medicines for patients, to promoting sustainability and spurring innovation.

Who was your mentor? What made her or him an effective mentor?

I’d like to spotlight MaryLynn Carver, hiring manager and coach when I transitioned from agency life to corporate life. She counseled me, she challenged me, she told me when to speed up and when to slow down, she inspired me, she encouraged me. She was a working mom of three, a cool jazz singer and someone who embraced life and made sure those around her were also enjoying what they were doing and growing. I’ve never told her this, and she may be surprised if she ends up reading this here!

What are you doing to mentor others — to send the career ladder back down, so to speak?

I am passionate about mentoring, particularly women. I have mentored many women over the years, formally, informally, scheduled, ad hoc. I lead the Women in Leadership group at my company. I am particularly keen on giving time to college students and new grads when they reach out from LinkedIn, Healthcare Businesswomen’s Association or other. I have been recognized externally for my mentoring efforts, but my inspiration is when I get a “thank-you” from someone whom I had mentored as they share their success since we met.

What’s something your colleagues don’t know about you?

They know I am competitive and an athlete. Maybe what they don’t know is that I have never owned an Apple watch, health monitor or app. I rely on listening to my body, exercising every day, eating well, sleeping and giving my best today because I have no idea what tomorrow may look like. My main goal is to keep the wolf at the door.

What are the three things in your daily workspace that you can’t live without?

Water. Pen. Pad of paper. I’m old school in my to-do lists and taking notes.

What is your favorite book (or TV show, movie, band or song)? What about it resonates strongly with you?

Unfair question. I enjoyed Brene Brown’s Atlas of the Heart and found myself driving under the speed limit when I listened. When I finished [Amor Towles’] The Lincoln Highway, I was compelled to listen to A Gentleman in Moscow — amazing writing! I laughed out loud with Kevin Hart’s I Can’t Make This Up and [Nita Prose’s] The Maid, and I cried with [Ann Pachett’s] The Dutch House. I thought again with [Adam Grant’s] Think Again, and I appreciate my 20-something sons with [Meg Jay’s] The Defining Decade. I have greater compassion for people with Oprah’s What Happened to You and greater love for people with The Bible.

What’s on your to-do list for when you retire?

I try to do these things now, but hopefully will get even better at it:

Be more present for loved ones (no more computer or email!)
Play golf
Volunteer
Paint
Read
…and play with future grandbabies.

AI-generated image wins photography award, but artist refuses to accept it

AI-generated image wins photography award, but artist refuses to accept it
The photo is part of a series titled PSEUDOMNESIAThe photo is part of a series titled PSEUDOMNESIA
The photo is part of a series titled PSEUDOMNESIA

Eldagsen 

The photo above has won a Sony World Photography Award in the creative open category, but there’s a problem. It’s AI-generated.

After winning, Berlin-based artist Boris Eldagsen posted on his blog: “Thank you for selecting my image and making this a historic moment, as it is the first AI generated image to win in a prestigious international PHOTOGRAPHY competition,”

Since then, the image has become the subject of a huge controversy in the AI art vs human art debate.

AI-generated image wins photography award, but artist refuses to accept it
The award winning photo in full

AI images and photography are different entities, and even Eldagsen seems to think so. He has refused to accept the award, emphasising on that AI and photography should not be competing in the same category. “AI is not photography. Therefore I will not accept the award.”

Why did he submit AI art into a photography competition?

While people are now slowly warming towards the powerful qualities and usefulness of artificial intelligence and its scope in terms of generating impressive images and graphics, there are folks who strongly believe that AI can represent genuine human artistic expression.

Eldagsen further wrote in his blog, “I applied as a cheeky monkey, to find out if the competitions are prepared for AI images to enter. They are not.”

AI-generated image wins photography award, but artist refuses to accept it
Boris Eldagsen

Eldagsen and the World Photography Organization (WPO), which hands out the Sony World Photography Awards, have locked horns over the issue. WPO is now claiming that they were aware that the image was co-created using AI before he was announced as the winner.

In response to this, Eldagsen said in his blog, “Pretending that you knew the picture was AI is wrong. I told one of your assistants in length, but then after the press release your PR executive contacted me, being surprised about all the inquiries regarding my image and asking for more info.”

The piece of art in question is part of a series called PSEUDOMNESIA – which Eldagsen explains is the Latin term for pseudo memory, a fake memory, such as a spurious recollection of events that never took place, as opposed to a memory that is merely inaccurate. Interestingly, Eldagsen’s website also mentions that the images in the series have been co-produced by the means of AI (artificial intelligence) image generators.

“We, the photo world, need an open discussion. A discussion about what we want to consider photography and what not. Is the umbrella of photography large enough to invite AI images to enter – or would this be a mistake? With my refusal of the award I hope to speed up this debate.”

Eldagsen studied photography and visual arts at the Art Academy of Mainz, conceptual art and intermedia at the Academy of Fine Arts, Prague and fine art the Sarojini Naidu School of Arts & Communication, Hyderabad.

Most Popular