Photography

GenAI and the Forced Evolution of Photography: From Artifice to Authenticity

GenAI and the Forced Evolution of Photography: From Artifice to Authenticity

The rise of Generative Artificial Intelligence has been nothing short of revolutionary, impacting every domain from finance to the arts. In the world of photography, GenAI has had a transformative effect, much like the impact photography once had on painting.

The Historical Parallel: Photography and Painting

When photography emerged in the 19th century, it provoked a crisis in the world of painting. No longer did painters need to act as the primary recorders of reality; photography could capture a scene with unparalleled accuracy and detail. This compelled painters to introspect, leading to movements like Impressionism, Expressionism, and Cubism. Painters began exploring the more abstract, emotional, and subjective aspects of art, areas where photography couldn’t intrude.

Is it photography, or is it GenAI? The question should rather be, is it authentic?

GenAI’s Emergence and Photography’s Dilemma

Today, GenAI poses a similar challenge to photographers. With the ability to fabricate hyper-realistic images, often indistinguishable from real photographs, GenAI blurs the line between reality and artificiality. If GenAI can recreate or even surpass the aesthetic appeal of a captured moment, what then becomes the essence of photography?

From Artifice to Authenticity

The response has been a compelling shift towards authenticity. In an age where GenAI can create realistic and artistic visuals, photography must return to its original purpose as a trusted recorder of reality. Art will be for painters and prompt engineers. Documenting reality will be for photographers. To maintain its integrity and relevance, photography is now being pushed to clearly demark itself from artificial creations. This means that photographers are gravitating towards:

Documentary-style photography: This involves capturing unaltered, candid moments, often with a focus on storytelling. By emphasizing the truth, photographers can offer something GenAI can’t fabricate – genuine human experiences. Think weddings, for example. No one will want GenAI images of the couple exchanging vows.

Photojournalism: Prioritizing truth over aesthetics, photojournalists aim to present an unbiased view of reality, further distancing themselves from the artifice of GenAI. A must for our democratic societies to thrive.

Emphasis on Process: Much like how painters celebrated the brushstroke post-photography, photographers will further highlight their unique processes, equipment choices, and techniques to differentiate their work from machine-generated images accompanied by certificates that verify each step of the process, ensuring it is firmly rooted in reality.

Beyond the Realism-Artifice Dichotomy

The push for realism doesn’t mean there’s no room for creativity in photography. On the contrary, photographers should merge realism with artistic interpretations. Use the “old” medium to explore deeper truths, playing with shadows, compositions, and contexts to evoke emotions and narratives, all while staying clearly rooted in authenticity.

A young boy running through a water sprinkler with the sun in the background
Do we really need to replicate this via AI, or is this better left to photography? Photo by MI PHAM on Unsplash

The Future of Photography in a GenAI World

Just as painting underwent a transformative evolution after the advent of photography, so too will photography evolve in response to GenAI. While GenAI boasts the ability to mimic and replicate, it cannot capture the human touch, the genuine intent, or the spontaneous moments that define a photographer’s click. Photography is more than just an image—it’s our connection to the real world, to one another, and to moments that inform our decisions. The next generation of photographers will become masters of probability, documenting reality with certitude. It’s this intrinsic human connection and touch with reality that will forever differentiate genuine photography from AI-generated imagery.

As the lines between the real and the artificial blur, photography’s role in preserving and portraying reality becomes even more paramount. While GenAI forces a reevaluation of the purpose and essence of photography, it certainly doesn’t diminish its value. Instead, it pushes photographers to evolve, to be more discerning in their approach, and to capture the world with an authenticity that only they can provide.


The opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author.


About the author: Paul Melcher is a photography and technology entrepreneur based in New York, and the founder of Kaptur, a news magazine about the visual tech space. You can find more of his writings on his blog, Thoughts of a Bohemian. Melcher offers his services as a consultant as well. This article was also published here.


Image credits: Header photo generated with Adobe Firefly

How Photographers Can Buy a Working Macbook Pro for Just $22 |

How Photographers Can Buy a Working Macbook Pro for Just $22 |

MacBook Pro computers have been the industry standard laptop for many years now. These machines usually cost a small fortune but can be found much cheaper if you’re willing to do a bit of detective work.

We all know Apple products come at a premium, and for some photographers, those price points are just too high. The good news is that with a little bit of Internet sleuthing and some basic computer repair skills, it is possible to get a MacBook Pro laptop for very little money.

This is exactly what technologist Luke Miani does when he hits eBay in search of a working Apple laptop at a rock-bottom price. The laptop he finds is a MacBook Pro (15-inch, Mid 2010) model that he paid just $22 for. The video goes on to show Miani testing the machine, installing a hard drive, and updating the operating system to get the laptop back to life. Minus the odd surface scratch, it really is hard to believe this MacBook has been around for 13 years.

In the second half of this video, Miani shows us how we can personally take advantage of eBay’s search filters to find similar bargains and what exactly we should be looking out for in a listing on the auction site. I really like Miani’s tips for hunting out these machines, and a quick look myself found a few candidates at similar price points.

The video does not shy away from the fact this machine is well over 10 years old and shows that for many applications, it is still more than usable. While such an old machine may struggle with some of the more memory-intensive tasks of a photographer in 2023, I do think you may be surprised by how much a laptop bought for $22 is still capable of. The main take-home here is that there are decent laptops out there that could be bought for very little and added to your arsenal of photo gear. One important point that isn’t mentioned in the video is that these older laptops mostly come with various USB, HDMI, and memory card slots that are often missing from newer machines but are still more than useful for photographers on the go. I personally love the idea of having a cheap dedicated laptop for doing some light editing while on location and at a price point that not only doesn’t break the bank but also wouldn’t be the end of the world if it got damaged or stolen.

Would you consider buying such an old laptop for your photography work? Is anyone still using older tech in this way? We’d love to hear from you in the comments below.

Willie Velazquez: One of NY’s Best Street Photographers

Willie Velazquez: One of NY’s Best Street Photographers

“I think over time you get better at spotting emotions, as well as gestures, compositions, and more because these are the things that you’re constantly looking for; The ingredients of a photo,” says Willie Velazquez, arguably one of NY’s best street photographers, to the Phoblographer in an interview. “I think you may even begin to take in the world in a different way compared to the people around you who don’t shoot.” He continues to state that sometimes, even he doesn’t know what he sees — but it’s a gut reflex to just shoot. Overall, he attributed some of his work to just pure luck.

All images by Willie Velazquez. Used with permission. Please visit his website and his Instagram for more.

How Willie Velazquez Started Out

Willie first started out in sales, and that kept things running for him into the end of his 20s when he was finally making good money. But for him, life became really monotonous and rigorous. “Days melted into each other, and sleep was minimal due to the 5+ coffees I had daily,” he describes to us. “When the coffee lost its effects, I began supplementing. That led to barely sleeping at all during the work week, which I made up for by sleeping in all day on weekends, waking only to eat, and sometimes socialize.” That’s when he realized he was burning out and it was time to try something else.

Growing up, Willie had a lot of cameras but wanted something more professional. So in 2019, he bought a Canon Rebel. “Afterwards I sat outside on a nearby bench, unboxed the camera, turned it on and almost immediately realized I had no idea what or who to shoot,” he tells us.

Willie was a rapper in a past life, and grew up with Hip Hop cover albums as a prime example of photography. He didn’t live that life anymore though, so he went to parks to photography. From there, he shot streets, buildings, and eventually started photographing people. “After a short while, I just started walking around with the camera everywhere I went,” Willie shares. “It could’ve been a 5-minute trip to the store and back; I’d have the camera on me, finger on the shutter at all times. I was in the beginning stages and didn’t even realize street photography was an actual thing yet.” Needless to say, he was hooked.

For a while, Willie shot film: specifically a Leica M6 and an Olympus Mju II. And these days, he’s been using a Leica M10p and a Ricoh GR III. “So far, it’s the longest I’ve gone without feeling the urge to buy another camera, so I’m feeling great about that,” he shares with us. “Depending on the day I’m either shooting 28, 35 or both. I’m really at home with those two focal lengths.” Besides this, he carries a flash.

The Creative Vision of One of NY’s Best Street Photographers

Somebody once told me they didn’t shoot the homeless, the disabled, children nor senior citizens. His work was unremarkable to me, as I’d expect. No life in it. Mostly hip shots and side profiles of people just walking in the street, and a considerable amount of shots from behind a person; portraits of the back of heads. But seldom did he shoot head on. He was dabbling, beginning. We all go through it.

Willie Velazquez

Willie’s thought process and creative vision are fascinating. While many street photographers shy away from photographing the homeless and disabled, Willie tends to embrace it in a way that tells a much larger story than what we tend to see from more green photographers. Part of this perhaps comes from his upbringing.

Instead, Willie tells us that he shoots without restrictions. And in many ways, his images tell a story of NY that isn’t being told. It’s one with economic disparity at the root. “…if there’s any consideration to be made, it’s in the curation of my work and what it is I choose to share,” Willie explains. “But when I’m outside and shooting, it’s mostly a reflex to what I see and the feeling it evokes, whatever that feeling may be. To put a restriction on that is not being true to the soul of the work.” In the long run, Willie thinks that it more or less just became a reflex.

Can’t speak on the professional implications since photography is yet to be my main source of income. But as far as AI itself I’d be more curious to know once it’s got a uniform, hive-minded opinion on the human race. But when it gets to that, photos will probably be the last thing to worry about.

“And morally speaking; is it really any better to treat any demographic like they don’t exist and make the effort to not include them in an art form I put my heart and sweat into?”

Of course, Willie’s work is also quite raw, and not the type of stuff that you’d ever see an AI duplicate. To that end, Willie thinks that AI is fun and that people are making some remarkable visuals with it. “There’s a series of Steve Harvey running from monsters in the woods that looks like they shot it on a Polaroid I think,” he says. “I can’t get enough of it.”

Fleetwood: How an ‘amazing community’ shaped an artist’s work

Fleetwood: How an ‘amazing community’ shaped an artist’s work
LindaHannah O’Hara

The seaside towns of England’s North West are places steeped in nostalgia for many, filled with echoes of childhood trips, ice creams and bracing walks along the prom.

Photographer Hannah O’Hara was no different when she was commissioned to create work that reflected Fleetwood’s “people, places and heritage”.

However, she says spending a year “immersing” herself in the Lancashire fishing port has also given her a new perspective.

And the driving force for that was, she says, a simple one.

“People are much more talkative than in the South.”

Hannah O'Hara

Hannah O’Hara

Craig Whitbread

Hannah O’Hara

O’Hara is based in Sussex, but her father lived in Blackpool when she was a child and she has “fond memories” of trips to Fleetwood.

So she jumped at the chance to return there for a year, thanks to a commission from photography charity Photoworks and Fleetwood High Street Heritage Action Zone‘s cultural programme.

And while she admits that immersing herself in the culture of the town, which included taking photography walks with residents and visiting care homes to speak to residents, “triggered nostalgic memories”, it also allowed her to embrace Fleetwood’s “amazing community”.

Seamstress Carol

Hannah O’Hara

Fleetwood radar tower

Hannah O’Hara

“People are so friendly,” she says.

“I have met and worked with so many kind individuals who have helped me develop this project and given their time freely and told their stories openly.

“It has been a privilege as an artist to hear their memories.”

The resulting exhibition, From Nothing to Now, shares the stories and images she has gathered and explores the themes that run through all her work – temporality, place and memory.

It includes both her own images and some of those taken by residents on their photography walks and is being shown across the town, in its museum, library and bustling market.

Local photographer Alan taking photograph on a walk in Fleetwood

Hannah O’Hara

Jean

Hannah O’Hara

The wider cultural programme’s arts engagement co-ordinator Angelica Vanasse says O’Hara’s “dedication” to the work and “getting to know the people in Fleetwood has helped to create opportunities for connection to shape the stories… in ways that are meaningful to people in the present”.

“Hannah has gotten to know people… across the high street and its businesses, in cultural organisations, care homes and in community environments,” she says.

“The exhibition… reflects their heritage, stories, memories and connection to place in ways that are rooted deeply in the present and being proud of the place they call home.”

Photoworks curator Julia Bunnemann says the strength of it is the result of the “strong connections” O’Hara has made with people “across all ages and backgrounds… from a diverse range of local communities”

“It has been brilliant to witness the genuine connections that have emerged as a result of her artistic exploration,” she adds.

From Nothing to Now is at Fleetwood Museum, Fleetwood Library and Fleetwood Market until 28 November.

Presentational grey line

Why not follow BBC North West on Facebook, X and Instagram? You can also send story ideas to northwest.newsonline@bbc.co.uk

Related Internet Links

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.

THNOC’s newest publication celebrates one of America’s leading photography curators – The New Orleans 100

THNOC’s newest publication celebrates one of America’s leading photography curators – The New Orleans 100

In “Louisiana Lens: Photographs from The Historic New Orleans Collection,” John H. Lawrence skillfully weaves a captivating visual narrative of New Orleans, Louisiana and the Gulf South.

Lawrence traces the evolution of photography from daguerreotypes to digital, contextualizing each image within the social and cultural fabric of the city. He explores themes of architecture, music, race and more. Accompanied by 131 black-and-white and 44 color photographs, the hardcover volume is a testament to Lawrence’s encyclopedic knowledge for visual culture.

Its price is $49.95 and may be purchased online and in person at The Shop at The Collection, THNOC’s museum store.

The Historic New Orleans Collection

Local photographer earns Masters

Local photographer earns Masters

Martinsville photographer Rick Dawson of Dawson Photography Inc., has been recognized for superior image making and photographic service with a degree from Professional Photographers of America.



Rick Dawson

Dawson




On Friday, Dawson earned the Master of Photography degree from Professional Photographers of America (PPA). The degree will be presented to Dawson by PPA President Kira Derryberry at the association’s annual convention in Louisville, Kentucky, in January, a release stated.

The Master of Photography degree means that Dawson has met the standards of excellence set by the PPA, recognizing his superior photographic competence demonstrated through image excellence, advanced education, and service to the profession, stated the release.

Dawson has been a freelance for the Martinsville Bulletin for many years and his photographs frequently appear in this newspaper.

People are also reading…

PPA is the largest and longest-standing nonprofit photography trade association and was founded in 1868. PPA currently works with 34,000 professional photographers, elevating their craft and growing their businesses with resources and education under the guiding principle of bridging the gap between photographers and consumers, the release stated. 

Bill Wyatt (276) 591-7543

bill.wyatt@martinsvillebulletin.com

@billdwyatt on Twitter

#lee-rev-content { margin:0 -5px; }
#lee-rev-content h3 {
font-family: inherit!important;
font-weight: 700!important;
border-left: 8px solid var(–lee-blox-link-color);
text-indent: 7px;
font-size: 24px!important;
line-height: 24px;
}
#lee-rev-content .rc-provider {
font-family: inherit!important;
}
#lee-rev-content h4 {
line-height: 24px!important;
font-family: “serif-ds”,Times,”Times New Roman”,serif!important;
margin-top: 10px!important;
}
@media (max-width: 991px) {
#lee-rev-content h3 {
font-size: 18px!important;
line-height: 18px;
}
}

#pu-email-form-business-email-article {
clear: both;

background-color: #fff;

color: #222;

background-position: bottom;
background-repeat: no-repeat;
padding: 15px 0 20px;
margin-bottom: 40px;
border-top: 4px solid rgba(0,0,0,.8);
border-bottom: 1px solid rgba(0,0,0,.2);

display: none;

}
#pu-email-form-business-email-article,
#pu-email-form-business-email-article p {
font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, “Segoe UI”, Helvetica, Arial, sans-serif, “Apple Color Emoji”, “Segoe UI Emoji”, “Segoe UI Symbol”;
}
#pu-email-form-business-email-article h2 {
font-size: 24px;
margin: 15px 0 5px 0;
font-family: “serif-ds”, Times, “Times New Roman”, serif;
}
#pu-email-form-business-email-article .lead {
margin-bottom: 5px;
}
#pu-email-form-business-email-article .email-desc {
font-size: 16px;
line-height: 20px;
margin-bottom: 5px;
opacity: 0.7;
}
#pu-email-form-business-email-article form {
padding: 10px 30px 5px 30px;
}
#pu-email-form-business-email-article .disclaimer {
opacity: 0.5;
margin-bottom: 0;
line-height: 100%;
}
#pu-email-form-business-email-article .disclaimer a {
color: #222;
text-decoration: underline;
}
#pu-email-form-business-email-article .email-hammer {

border-bottom: 3px solid #222;

opacity: .5;
display: inline-block;
padding: 0 10px 5px 10px;
margin-bottom: -5px;
font-size: 16px;
}
@media (max-width: 991px) {
#pu-email-form-business-email-article form {
padding: 10px 0 5px 0;
}
}
.grecaptcha-badge { visibility: hidden; }

PAW-SOME! The winners of the 2023 Dog Photography Awards revealed

PAW-SOME! The winners of the 2023 Dog Photography Awards revealed
  • Delightful dogs in all shapes and sizes are captured in this year’s photography awards that had 1,400 entries 
Advertisement

The results are in for the 2023 Dog Photography Awards – and the shortlist includes everything from a Doberman in a tutu to a Sighthound showcasing its formidable speed.

The delightful collection, which is sure to put a smile on your face, is split into four categories; accepting entries for portrait and landscape snaps, action shots, studio images and dogs and people.

There was a grand total of 1,440 entries this year, from more than 50 countries – including China, Germany, Australia, and Canada – and this year’s prizes vary from photo equipment to €2,000 in cash.

This year the prize for winning studio portrait was awarded to Montenegro-based photographer Anna Averianova for her image ‘Ballerina’, which shows her pet Doberman dressed in a black tutu and pointing his paw like one of the elegant dancers.

This year the prize for winning studio portrait was awarded to Montenegro-based photographer Anna Averianova for her image 'Ballerina'

Bagging the prize for best portrait and landscape shot was Swedish photographer Sanna Sander, who submitted a photo of her pet azawakh girl Soleil sprawling across a log stack

Taking the top spot in the action photography category was Jacqueline Rüdiger, from Germany, for a shot of her Sighthound in 'Stop your motion'

Alessandro Grandoni, from Italy, submitted 'Guess on fly' in the action category

Carla Gea Perales, from Spain, won second place in the studio category for her image 'Just dance'

Roberta Holden was awarded second place in the action category for her piece 'Moment of Entry'

Second place for portrait and landscape was awarded to Grace Fieselman for her shot of Nala, her Australian Shepherd

Sanna Sander came in third place for the category portrait and landscape

Taking the top spot in the action photography category was Jacqueline Rüdiger, from Germany, for a shot of her Sighthound in ‘Stop your motion’.

She said of her work: ‘Have you ever seen a dog, or even better a sighthound, running in pure joy? You see the power, the play of the muscles and the perfect anatomy for running fast. 

‘In this picture I wanted to show the speed of this dog and capture it, but at the same time freeze the motion to show the anatomy of this beautiful dog. 

‘To get it you need a perfect timing of all components involved. The dog, the lights and for sure me as the photographer. The result is a stunning composition reduced to the only important thing, the dog.’

Bagging the prize for best portrait and landscape shot was Swedish photographer Sanna Sander, who submitted a photo of her pet azawakh girl Soleil sprawling across a log stack.

Aptly titled ‘Ascending Serenity’, she explained: ‘In the right light even the most mundane place emits magic.

‘I had the idea of this image in my mind for quite some time, driving past the log stack every day on my way to drop the kids of at school. And finally, on our way home from school one day, I stopped the car and asked my azawakh girl Soleil to hold the pose for a moment while I took the photo.

'Puppy love' by Tuss Bennergård came in third place for the studio category with her shot of three weeks old Great Dane puppies

Emma Gough got the second place award for dogs and people with her shot 'Facing the Immensity Together'

German-based Tina Stahl captured an image of her Dachshund, Maddie, staring at her treats

Polish Iulia Tulcinscaia captured her Beagle chewing on an apple

'Golden girls', by Rosalind Phang, shows A Belgian Malinois and a Belgian Shepherd running in front of the Eiffel Tower in Paris during sunrise

Stine Grind, from Sweden, shows her fury friends 'exploring the big world'

In third place for dog's and people, Jane Thomson won the award for 'Timber's Tribute'

The same photographer made the shortlist for the shot of her chihuahua in 'Chairman of the Board'

Janneke de Graaf showcased her 'elegant and graceful' Basenji dog

Spanish-based photographer Rut Casanellas named her shot 'Sharing is funny'

Michelle Dawkins pictured her dog flying through the water at sunset for her action entry

For the portrait and landscape category, Katie Brockman submitted 'seeing double'

Kyle Rurak put her entry forward for dogs and people, naming the shot 'Ziggy meets Josslyn'

‘Already in the camera I saw that it had become something more than I had hoped for; a moment of clean stillness in the busy and messy everyday life, something more than a posing dog on a log stack. The image made me linger in the moment.’

For the dogs and people category, Australian Mercury Megaloudis took her inspiration from Italian painter Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio, known as simply Caravaggio.

She used the ‘New and the old Inspired by Caravaggio the artist and new trends in steampunk with the love of dogs all in the studio’ for her work. 

Other winning photos from this year’s competition included a ‘man’s best friend’ posing alongside a man in a suit with an umbrella on the beach.

In another adorable snap, three weeks old Great Dane puppies cuddled up together under a warm studio light.

The competition is held annually, with other contests for dog photographers taking place on a monthly basis.

Audrey Bellot, DPA Founder said: ‘The Dog Photography Awards has once again showcased the remarkable talent within the world of dog photography. 

‘Witnessing emerging artists capture the essence of canine beauty with their stunning imagery remains the standout event of the year.’ 

Photographer’s work featured in ‘beautiful exhibit’ explores how race, identity shaped Richmond

Photographer’s work featured in ‘beautiful exhibit’ explores how race, identity shaped Richmond

RICHMOND, Va. — When Richmond photographer Barrett Miller first started his passion project, the VCU graduate says he never imagined it would be the basis for the first exhibit he would be a part of.

“These portraits have allowed me to have conversations with people and to build community, and so in doing that you realize how different we all are, but how similar we are, too,” said Miller.

Richmond photographer Barrett Miller
Richmond photographer Barrett Miller

Titled “Streets of Ella,” inspired by Ella Fitzgerald, the collection of portraits is just one part of the “Race in Richmond” exhibit.

“Music inspires my creative vision, so I thought it was only right to name this beautiful exhibit of people after one of my favorite artists,” said Miller.

Hosted at the Well Collective, the four-part exhibit explores race and identity in Richmond through photography, storytelling and interactive experiences.

“Tonight is a night of acknowledgment in people sharing their stories of what it’s like to be in their body based on the color of their skin but also based on their identity,” said CEO of the Well Collective, Ashley Williams. “Creating spaces of healing where each of us are seen for who we are, seen for how we show up and we can just create a better space for the people around us.”

CEO of the Well Collective CEO Ashley Williams
Well Collective CEO Ashley Williams

With over 200 in attendance, the event included a live painting, portrait taking and exhibits featuring the work of more than 5 local artist.

Both artist and attendees were grateful for the curation of this multi layered experience and hopeful for the message it was making.

“It’s such an emotional experience to go through an exhibit like this,” attendee Briana Williams explained. “It’s so important that we take the time to share our experiences of racism, so many different forms of it. It’s there every day. But also take the time to reflect on how we can change and how we can be better people and support others.”

Poster image - 2023-11-04T082012.762.jpg

Exhibits like “Race in Richmond” are made possible by the surrounding community and artist apart of it. If your hoping to support, you can email raceinrichmond@gmail.com or visit their website.

Every day CBS 6 is giving a voice to the stories happening in your community. If you have a story idea, email our team at NewsTips@wtvr.com or click here to submit a tip.

image

📱More Richmond news from WTVR.com