About

Posts by :

Painting stolen 60 years ago turns up in Lancashire village

Painting stolen 60 years ago turns up in Lancashire village
Art Recovery International Flower Market Madeline by Edouard Léon CortèsArt Recovery International
The painting is by celebrated French artist Edouard Léon Cortès

A painting stolen from a New York art gallery 60 years ago has been found 3,000 miles away in a Lancashire village.

Art conservationists are celebrating after Flower Market Madeline by Edouard Léon Cortès turned up in Mawdesley.

Art Recovery International was alerted to the painting when a Lancashire-based art dealer offered it up for sale online.

The painting was originally displayed in the Herbert Arnot Gallery.

It was one of 3,000 works stolen over a 12-year period in the 1950s and 1960s by the former gallery manager Louis Edelman.

Edelman was eventually arrested in Chicago by the FBI in the 1960s and convicted of transporting stolen artworks across state lines.

He was jailed for two years and given a $10,000 fine, but most of the paintings were never recovered.

Art Recovery International FBI agents standing next to stolen paintings that have been recoveredArt Recovery International
FBI agents foiled Edelman’s scheme in the 1960s and recovered a number of works

Flower Market Madeline, which depicts a flower market in the style of other street artworks by the French artist, was bought in November 2022 by Carnes Fine Art from the Manchester-based Capes Dunn auction house.

Bradley Carnes, director of Carnes Fine Art, said he paid more than £10,000 for the work and said he was shocked when Art Recovery International contacted him after he advertised it for sale on his website.

He said: “I always look for provenance, so gallery labels, certificates, receipts and so forth to make sure that the painting is actually genuine and not a fake, but you don’t think about them being stolen.

“Initially I thought it was a scam, but through a quick Google search I found out the person contacting me was the head of Art Recovery International.

“From the outset, we got on really well and we just made sure that this painting got back to its rightful owner in New York.”

Mr Carnes was eventually reimbursed for the painting.

Christopher Marinello, a lawyer and founder of Art Recovery International, spent several months unwinding the sale.

He found that the painting had been consigned to Capes Dunn in 2022 by a Cheshire estate who confirmed that it was acquired from the MacConnal-Mason Gallery in London.

Mr Marinello said: “We are very grateful to Bradley Carnes, Capes Dunn, and their vendor for releasing this stolen painting unconditionally to the Arnot Gallery.

“While in this instance we were able to convince many of the parties to reimburse the other, eventually there will be those who are out of luck.

“I cannot stress enough the importance of performing due diligence and authentication checks which would have uncovered this stolen painting decades earlier.”

Mr Marinello urged anyone buying or selling paintings by Edouard-Leon Cortés to check with the Arnot Gallery for proper authentication.

“We have been recovering one or two pictures per year from this 60-year-old theft and we’re never going to give up until every last one is returned,” he said.

Presentational grey line

Why not follow BBC North West on Facebook, X and Instagram? You can also send story ideas to northwest.newsonline@bbc.co.uk



Copyright 2023 BBC. All rights reserved.  The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.

Beta Terms By using the Beta Site, you agree that such use is at your own risk and you know that the Beta Site may include known or unknown bugs or errors, that we have no obligation to make this Beta Site available with or without charge for any period of time, nor to make it available at all, and that nothing in these Beta Terms or your use of the Beta Site creates any employment relationship between you and us. The Beta Site is provided on an “as is” and “as available” basis and we make no warranty to you of any kind, express or implied.

In case of conflict between these Beta Terms and the BBC Terms of Use these Beta Terms shall prevail.

Review | In the galleries: Clay becomes a metaphor for the body and the Earth

Review | In the galleries: Clay becomes a metaphor for the body and the Earth

Among the goals of Ara Koh’s show at Hamiltonian Artists is to reimagine landscape painting as something literally derived from the land. Other objects in the Seoul-born local artist’s “Grounding; Grounded; Ground” equate clay with flesh. According to the unorthodox ceramist’s statement, she is “trying to understand earth, humanness.” To do that, she uses materials excavated and shaped with her own hands.

Sharp. Witty. Thoughtful. Sign up for the Style Memo newsletter.

Several pieces were made by slathering various kinds of clay — including kaolin, a soft white substance used for porcelain — on canvases or wooden panels. These painting-like objects are defined by crags, fractures and subtle color shifts. One appears to be merely a large hanging sheet, draped and creased. Only close inspection reveals that its surface is covered with patterns made by dried, cracked kaolin.

A few of Koh’s creations recall traditional building materials such as terra-cotta tiles, while others derive from natural forms. Nests of stoneware curls in tan, white or greenish blue evoke vines and tendrils (and recall the work of another masterly local ceramicist, Laurel Lukaszewski). Two pieces array concentric ovals or circles made of stoneware that looks as thin and fragile as skin. Inside one is a mix of glass and resin that simulates water, which is as essential to pottery as clay. The glistening green depths suggest another thing that’s full of water: the human body.

Ara Koh: Grounding; Grounded; Ground Through Dec. 2 at Hamiltonian Artists, 1353 U St. NW. hamiltonianartists.org. 202-332-1116.

Staking Claim

Amy Kaslow Gallery often exhibits Indigenous crafts, but its current show takes a more complicated approach to traditional goods-making. Most of the 13 contributors to “Staking Claim: Native American Artists on Identity & Place” meld elements of their threatened cultures with Euro-American techniques. The show overlaps with the National Gallery of Art’s “The Land Carries Our Ancestors,” sharing Muscogee-Creek painter George Alexander (also known as Ofuskie). He uses an expressionist style to paint a bare-chested man on horseback who appears timeless save for one detail: He wears an astronaut’s helmet.

Seminole artist Tony Tiger employs traditional elements but combines them in a contemporary manner, layering colorful textile designs over old photographs of Native people. Another collagist, Montana Blackfoot artist Terrance Guardipee, assembles maps, photos, ID cards and vintage financial documents, placing them on wooden triangles or skateboard decks — a form of transportation somewhere between the horse and the spaceship. Hopi artist Larsen Harris Jr. uses traditional knife whittling to make kachina dolls, representations of spirit beings he embellishes with feathers and plant fibers.

Such potters as Jerome Ebelackerand Sharon Naranjo Garcia (both heirs to Santa Clara Pueblo’s ceramics practice) and Cavan Gonzales (whose Tewa name is Tse-Whang) produce vessels with elegant curves and iridescent dark finishes. Ira Lujan (Taos/Ohkay Owingeh Pueblo) uses an old-world art — glass-blowing — to produce solid-glass antlers that he pairs with gnarled found wood. Simultaneously rustic and sophisticated, these sculptural collages are traditional in spirit if not method.

Staking Claim: Native American Artists on Identity & Place Through Dec. 3 at Amy Kaslow Gallery, 7920 Norfolk Ave., Bethesda. amykaslowgallery.com.

Elaine Florimonte

Literally as well as figuratively layered, Elaine Florimonte’s abstracted landscapes are built like the Earth itself: bit by bit, but with epic results. The pictures in her Touchstone Gallery show, “Lost and Found,” have a sense of both immediate movement and long-term action. Their cinematic compositions impel the eye to rush across land and sea, while offering a sense of the slow accumulation of random particles that gradually become mountains and oceans.

End of carousel

The local artist begins by assembling bits of paper, cutting and pasting maps and a set of bags whose green stripes underlie many of these pictures. Above these fragments she paints waves, rocks and horizon lines. The colorful gestures are echoed or contrasted by loosely sketched pencil lines.

Most sweeping are three large seascapes that suggest the hard surfaces below the fluid, cold-hued water. But the artist also conjures vastness with small artworks presented in sequence, such as the 20-square picture “November Series.” Even when Florimonte crops the view into tightly framed vignettes, she evokes a feeling of a much larger world.

Elaine Florimonte: Lost and Found Through Dec. 3 at Touchstone Gallery, 901 New York Ave. NW. touchstonegallery.com. 202-682-4125.

Julia Wachtel

Impending climate disaster is distilled into a series of toy animals in “Plastic Fantasy,” Julia Wachtel’s show at Von Ammon Co. Painted in a crisp, photorealist style, the babyish creatures might be seen simply as metaphors for commercial banality and fetishized innocence. But each picture of a molded-plastic figurine is stacked vertically above or below a large photo-derived print of a factory, ocean or container ship.

The paintings pick up the color schemes of the prints: A blue elephant is paired with a seascape, and a gray-and-yellow cat perches atop a refinery suffused with yellow and orange fire. The photos are four-color halftones enlarged to varying degrees, so the dots that make up the images are more prominent in some than others. The effect is to make the pictures come into focus at differing vantage points, as if each scene must be evaluated separately.

The toys, meanwhile, are rendered by Wachtel’s brush as precisely as by the machines that made the originals. Manufactured cheaply but uniformly, they may well outlast the animal species they cartoonishly represent.

Julia Wachtel: Plastic Fantasy Through Dec. 2 at Von Ammon Co., 3330 Cady’s Alley NW. vonammon.co. 202-893-9797.

Local poet, activist, artist and filmmaker Roy Utley devised a hybrid peace-symbol and clenched-fist logo that’s featured in several pieces in his Otis Street Arts Project exhibition. But most of “Live! From the Chair” is devoted to words, notably a set of poetic musings from the seat where he received chemotherapy treatments for prostate cancer. Utley died three days after the show’s Oct. 28 opening.

Organized by the artist’s son, Jacob Utley, the survey includes videos as well as “peace fists” executed in cut paper or with thick blobs of white paint on a red background. The most complicated artwork is an all-text schematic diagram, “The Art of Peace,” that stretches horizontally (and historically) from pre-Socratic philosopher Heraclitus to epochal pacifist Mohandas K. Gandhi. Viewers of this amusing, erudite and idiosyncratic document may wish that Utley was still around to discuss it with them.

Roy Utley: Live! From the Chair Through Dec. 2 at Otis Street Arts Project, 3706 Otis St., Mount Rainier. otisstreetarts.org.

‘Humans of Heaven’ Offers Compelling Saint Stories, One Photograph and Biography at a Time

‘Humans of Heaven’ Offers Compelling Saint Stories, One Photograph and Biography at a Time

New book by Catholic shop owner tells the stories of 50 holy men and women.

Humans of Heaven

By Jana Zuniga Pingel

January Jane Shop, 2023

167 pages, $39.95

To order: JanuaryJaneShop.com

More valuable than the sweetly simple exterior of Humans of Heaven is the beauty of the holy men and women who fill the pages within.

Humans of Heaven has a sort of “ever ancient, ever new” motif, telling the stories of 50 holy men and women acknowledged by the Church, who lived throughout history, yet whose stories speak to the heart of our own lives in the present day. So that the reader has a clear understanding, author Jana Zuniga Pingel begins the book with a short explanation of who the saints are and offers a brief list of key terms. As such, it is suitable for cradle Catholics, converts and anyone else on the journey heavenward.

“When you hold this book in your hands, I hope you feel the tangible presence of the army of God,” Pingel writes.

That hope has certainly been actualized, at least for this reader.

The 50 profiles span a wide range of decades and devotions. Readers will enjoy the entries on well-known saints such as St. Thérèse of Lisieux, St. Josemaría Escrivá and St. John Paul II. Within the same sitting, one may learn about newer and lesser-known saints (or saints-to-be) like Blessed Karl of Austria or Servant of God Michelle Duppong.

Each holy profile features a vintage photograph, a short summary of the holy life, a beautifully hand-calligraphic quote by the author, and quick facts such as hometown, birth and death date, feast day and patronage.

Pingel reveals their humanness amid their heroic virtue. “These stories help materialize what it means to live according to the Gospel in modern society,” Pingel told the Register. “These 50 testimonies are approachable, yet challenging.”

While the photos from saints to Servants of God are printed in black and white, their stories are told in full of color.

Each page is replete with edifying, harrowing recounts of these men and women who courageously stood for truth, beauty and goodness in the face of disaster, disease and devastation. Some pages feature saints who crossed oceans and traveled to wild lands to share the Gospel, while others offer a glimpse into the daily life of men and women who lived in their quiet towns and silent cloisters.

Humans of Heaven was born from both my personal relationship with these 50 modern saints and a cry for hope in a post-Christian world,” Pingel said. With every line, the reader is sure to be filled with greater gratitude for the communion of saints and, hopefully, become ever-more inclined to call upon these heavenly friends.

It is clear that authentic devotion was the motivation for this work. “Having grown up with a deep love and friendship with the saints myself, it was a natural response to keep sharing about them,” she told the Register.

As Pingel shares about her own connection to the Church triumphant, she invites the reader to do the same. “I call them my dear friends,” Pingel writes. “…They have made the narrow road towards heaven feel crowded during times of doubt and fear.”

From rags to royalty, the path to heaven is lined with footsteps of men and women journeying in profoundly distinct and individual ways, and Humans of Heaven captures this masterfully. It is an ode to the beauty and diversity of personal vocation, while at the same time being a triumphant testimony to the universal call to holiness, to which we have each been invited to partake.

Pingel shared her own surprise at selling more than 1,000 copies in less than three days of the book’s debut on her website. This book certainly has the quality of a domestic-church staple. “It seems obvious now that God has put his finger on this book and had bigger plans for it than I did,” she told the Register.

While Humans of Heaven will add an aesthetic element to a coffee table, it goes much deeper than decor. While excerpts may be read in minutes, readers will be drawn into reflection for days to follow.

There are many ways one might enjoy Humans of Heaven: Read one story each evening with tea after dinner. Use as an accompaniment to morning prayer. Let it be a liturgical companion while celebrating feasts days with family or home-schooling children.

Pingel told the Register her ultimate hope for this book is that readers will be “given hope, encouragement and a deeper conviction in the power of their personal vocation to sainthood.”

Baldy’s snow artists deserve credit

Baldy’s snow artists deserve credit

Snow farming is a tough industry that in most years causes more nail biting than others. With few exceptions, the Sun Valley area waits every year to see if Mother Nature will bestow bountiful blessings of frozen water or withhold them like a fickle friend.

Fortunately, the largesse of Sun Valley Resort long ago made snow on Bald Mountain more predictable by installing one of the largest snowmaking operations in the world. With every new run, the resort expands the system. Even without large quantities of natural snow, Baldy is enjoyably skiable and comfortable every winter. The resort is doing a terrific job.

Engineers who design snowmaking systems know that all snow is not the same. Its crystal structure changes as it forms within clouds and changes again as it floats to the earth below.

At the National Gallery, a clear sign of contemporary Indigenous art on the rise

At the National Gallery, a clear sign of contemporary Indigenous art on the rise

WASHINGTON, D.C. — Mirror-sheen planks bounce the blue sky back to a drone-mounted camera as they spiral and flow over muddy snow in Cannupa Hanska Luger’s “Mirror Shield Project- River (The Water Serpent),” a video piece he made during the 2016 pipeline protests on the Standing Rock Indian Reservation in the Dakotas. It’s inevitably among the first things you see in “The Land Carries Our Ancestors: Contemporary Art by Native Americans” at the National Gallery of Art, a broad and absorbing exhibition that spans media, generations, and geography.

The piece captures a stirringly poetic act of resistance. Luger, who was born on the reservation, gave protesters the planks to buffer themselves from encroaching law enforcement, there to make way for pipeline construction. The shields were protective and reflective: police and members of the National Guard approaching the protesters would have to confront themselves at the same time.

“Mirror Shield Project,” by Cannupa Hanska Luger. Action on Nov. 18, 2016, at Oceti Sakowin Camp, Standing Rock, N.D. Cannupa Hanska Luger/Garth Greenan Gallery, New York City

In recent years, the “Mirror Shield Project” has become something more, too. It’s been shown at museums at least a dozen times — I’ve seen it at the Peabody Essex Museum in Salem, in two different shows; and at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York. The piece is also on view now at Bard College’s Hessel Museum of Art in upstate New York in an exhibition of Native American performance and activism that closes Nov. 26. Is it too soon to call it totemic? I’m not sure. But it’s one of those rare works that a canon can be built with, a galvanizing piece that fires the imagination about what art can do.

“The Land Carries Our Ancestors,” curated by the Salish-Kootenai artist Jaune Quick-To-See Smith, feels full of such works, which makes it a landmark in all kinds of ways. The art world has been spotty at best in making space for contemporary Indigenous art. With nearly 50 artists, Smith’s show is the first major contemporary Indigenous survey exhibition at the gallery in 70 years, and the clearest signal so far of a broad shift, long overdue.

“To Feel Myself Beloved on the Earth,” by Jeffrey Gibson, 2020. Hirshhorn Museum and Sculpture Garden, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C. Jason Wyche/Sikkema Jenkins & Co., New York

A visible emblem of that shift, the artist Jeffrey Gibson, who is Choctaw-Cherokee, was selected to represent the United States at next year’s Venice Biennale, the contemporary art world’s most significant and prestigious event. Smith herself had a career retrospective at the Whitney Museum of American Art earlier this year. But there are signs everywhere, and notably in New England. The Museum of Fine Arts has slipped Native American art into collection displays, where Norval Morrisseau, who was Anishinaabe, and Preston Singletary, who is Tlingit, share space with American giants like Georgia O’Keeffe and Arthur Dove. The museum also just opened an exhibition of contemporary Indigenous prints, signaling a growing area of its collection. In the recently re-installed permanent collection at the Portland Museum of Art, contemporary Indigenous worldviews infuse the analysis of work by American icons such as Winslow Homer and Albert Bierstadt.

At Colby College, an exhibition centered on early-20th-century paintings of Native Americans by white artists who relocated to New Mexico is deepened with responses by contemporary Pueblo artists eager to rewrite those histories and speak for themselves. Back in Boston, Tufts University Art Galleries are hosting two exhibitions with of-the-moment concerns. “Vexoa: We Know,” at their Medford gallery, showcases Indigenous artists from Brazil as they grapple with the dire threat of development of the Amazon rain forest. At Tufts’s downtown campus in the Fenway, Elizabeth James Perry, an enrolled member of the Aquinnah Wampanoag tribe on Martha’s Vineyard, this fall crafted a paean to the natural world with delicate weaving and jewelry work built from materials close at hand near her home.

“Fog Bank” by Emmi Whitehorse (Diné), 2020. National Gallery of Art/Emmi Whitehorse

An accelerating climate emergency makes a disturbingly apt backdrop for contemporary Indigenous art. In Washington, Smith’s exhibition is explicitly about Native American stewardship and spiritual connections to the land, regardless of geography and tribal affiliation. Built into that is an indictment, and a lament, for colonialism’s violent severing of those connections, and how the natural world has been under increasing threat from post-colonial profiteering.

Luger’s work is an obvious example, but there are more subtle gestures, too. The rich, blue haze of Diné painter Emmi Whitehorse’s “Fog Bank,” 2020, with delicate flotsam adrift stirs notions of infection, impurity, contamination. Will Wilson’s lush, silvery photographic panorama of a view from atop a Southwestern mesa reverses the conventional notion of a sublime landscape with an urgent modern anxiety. He calls it “Auto-Immune Response no. 2,” one of a series of apocalyptic visions of a future where his ancestral Diné lands are little more than a beautiful corpse, toxified beyond repair. The figures in the foreground are gas-masked against the danger.

“Auto-Immune Response no. 2” by Will Wilson (Diné), 2004.Will Wilson

In the midst of “Mirror Shield Project,” you can see a new canon taking shape. Rose B. Simpson’s “Tontanzin,” 2021, is here, a sinister, earthly effigy of a maternal goddess in the ruddy orange clay of the Southwest. The Santa Clara Pueblo artist’s recent appearances at Mass MoCA, the MFA and the Institute of Contemporary Art Boston have made her all but a fixture around here, not to mention beyond. Seneca artist Marie Watt’s collaborative soft sculptures have brought notions of community and care to PEM and 18 other American art museums this year alone. At the National Gallery, “Antipodes,” 2020, her glass bead quilts juxtapose the terms “Skywalker” and “Skyscraper,” the latter famously built by the former, Indigenous ironworkers laboring hundreds of feet above Manhattan in the early 20th century. And of course, Gibson, whose 2020 beaded punching bag sculpture here — “To Feel Myself Beloved on the Earth,” it reads, in red boldface against a geometric pattern — feels like an invitation to release built-up frustration from the litany of affronts to the natural world. (Gibson’s solo exhibition at the deCordova in Lincoln was a highlight of 2021.)

This photo captures the “checkerboard” display that curator Jaune Quick-to-See Smith conceived to represent federal appropriations of Indigenous lands in the 19th century.Rob Shelley

In an expansive grid of dozens of smaller photographic pieces and works on paper, Smith deploys an array of strategies, media, and concerns that makes the breadth of contemporary Indigenous practice both obvious and wildly engaging. Wendy Red Star, who is Apsáalooke, is here (and also in collections at the MFA and PEM) with “The (HUD),” 2010, a print of a stack of modular housing, the likes of which the federal Housing and Urban Development agency threw together on reservations like hers, the Crow reservation in Montana. It contrasts with the delicate untitled 2021 abstraction of Luzene Hill, who is Cherokee; an earthy stain of ink, charcoal, tea, and gouache, it coaxes forth a fragile imprint of distress with the elemental presence of the planet itself.

What’s not here is as important as what is. A subtle undercurrent of the display is its checkerboard pattern, an echo of the 1887 federal Dawes Act, which carved out tracts of Indigenous land for settlers and interspersed them with their new Native neighbors.

The encroachment was at least partly designed to fracture Native communities, which it surely did. The way back remains long and filled with bureaucratic snafus, but Native communities are putting the pieces back together as never before. Given the looming environmental disasters, we should all hope so.

“Orchestrating a Blooming Desert” by Steven Yazzie (Diné/Pueblo of Laguna, New Mexico/European descent), 2003. Collection of Christy Vezolles. Heard Museum/Craig Smith

Diné artist Stephen Yazzie’s “Orchestrating a Blooming Desert,” 2003, a vivid painting of an Indigenous man conducting the blossoming of myriad life amid the arid landscape, is a little on-the-nose, conceptually; but please, take his point: It’s about the land, who knows it, and who can care for it best.

Can these ideas, finally, truly break through? The good news is they already have, and well outside the art world bubble. Prominent think tanks like The Wilson Center have brought forward Indigenous strategies in the battle against climate change, and the 2021 Glasgow Climate Summit featured the work of Indigenous activists deep in the fight, too.

Official American history and culture — written and defined, as ever, by the victors — has suppressed, quelled, or disregarded Indigenous knowledge and culture for centuries. Amid what feels like a genuine resurgence, let’s hope it will be different this time.

THE LAND CARRIES OUR ANCESTORS: Contemporary Art by Native Americans

At National Gallery of Art, East Building, 4th St. NW, Washington, D.C. Through Jan. 15. 202-737-4215, www.nga.gov


Murray Whyte can be reached at murray.whyte@globe.com. Follow him @TheMurrayWhyte.